
Auckland Institute.
Annual General Meeting. 21st May, 1873.
T. Heale, President, in the chair.
New members.—M. Hannaford, W. Scott, H. M. Williams, A. Cox, C. B. Knorpp, C.E., J. Slatter, E. Thomas, R. Stockwell, M.D., W. J. Cawkwell.
Abstract Report of the Council.
Seven meetings have been held during the year, at which twenty-one papers were read.
The number of visitors to the Museum has been larger than during any previous year. Considerable additions have been made to the Museum and Library, and also to the Herbarium.
In addition to the ordinary work of the Institute, considerable assistance has been afforded to the public in the identification of minerals, birds, insects, and plants, affording proof of the readiness of a small section of the community to avail itself of a portion of the advantages offered by the Institute.
The Council believe that much of the interest manifested in scientific pursuits is due to the annual volume of “Transactions.” They would also call attention to the Natural History Catalogues, issued by the Geological Survey Department, and have especial pleasure in recording the efforts being made to establish classes for the study of certain branches of natural science in connection with the Auckland College and Grammar School.
The receipts for the year ending 19th May, 1873, amount to £280 4s. 8d., and the expenditure to £228 4s. 9d., leaving a balance of £51 19s. 11d. The expenditure includes, however, the expenses for three months of the current year. The subscriptions for the year amount to £187 19s.
Election of Officers for 1873
Election of Officers for 1873.—President—His Honour T. B. Gillies; Council—J. L. Campbell, M.D., T. Heale, C.E., J. Stewart, C.E., T. Kirk, F.L.S., Rev. J. Kindér, D.D., D. Hay, H. H. Lusk, T. Russell, Hon. Colonel Haultain, Rev. A. G. Purchas, M.R.C.S.E., T. F. S. Tinne; Auditor—C. Tothill.
Resolved—That the thanks of the society be presented to the President and Council for their services during the past year.

Resolved—That the thanks of the society be presented to the Secretary, Thomas Kirk, Esq., F.L.S., for the zealous manner in which his duties have been performed, and that a separate record of this resolution be made on the minutes of this meeting.
Second Meeting. 9th June, 1873.
His Honour T. B. Gillies, President, in the chair.
New members.—J. A. Pond, J. Anderson, L. D. Nathan, W. Goodfellow, F. J. Moss.
The list of donations to the Library and Museum was read by the Secretary.
The President delivered the following anniversary
Address.
In opening the sixth session of this Institute I cannot refrain from congratulating you on the progress and prosperity of our institution. When, six years ago, our first President (Mr. Whitaker) addressed you at the opening of the institution, he—notwithstanding the encouragement to be derived from the small beginnings of the Royal Society of England and the Academy of France, which he adduced—ventured only to express “a wavering hope,” “rather than a belief,” in our future career. And though in some respects our society has not attained to the usefulness to which its founders hoped it would have attained, in others it has, I think, exceeded their most sanguine anticipations. When I observe that our original 68 members in 1868 have now increased to 185; when I see that we stand first on the list of affiliated societies to the New Zealand Institute in point of numbers; when I observe that we stand second only to the central institution at Wellington in either the number or quality of contributions towards recording scientific facts, I think we have reason to congratulate ourselves on the success of our institution. Our contributors of papers have been fewer than I could have desired and, I think, fewer than they might have been, and the attendance at our meetings smaller than I had hoped for; nevertheless, the contributions to our Museum, and the numbers of visitors to it, prove that our efforts have not been altogether unavailing in maintaining and increasing an interest in the pursuit and results of physical science. Many of you, I doubt not, have planted shrubs and trees, the growth of which you have attentively watched, and, I doubt not, have observed that, as a rule, your short-lived shrubs have in growth rapidly outstripped your trees whose age can only be measured by centuries; that your long-lived trees take many years ere they put forth strong, vigorous shoots, and very many more ere they produce either blossom

or fruit. But, for all that, they are making meanwhile the underground roots, which will hereafter nourish and sustain them. And so it is, and I trust will be, with this society, that meanwhile, without much show or pretence, we are spreading out roots and preparing for the bloom and fruit of future years.
There is one thing, however, which is essential to the fair growth of any tree, however hardy and well adapted to its soil, namely, shelter. And I feel certain that the growing energies of our society must be rendered largely unavailing unless we obtain better shelter for our Library and Museum than we now have. We have already, in our Library, a large number of scientific works of reference, some of them, I believe, unique in the colony. We have specimens in various branches of science in our Museum, some of them unique, and others which could scarcely be replaced if destroyed, and yet these are not only comparatively valueless to the public and to the student, because of the inconvenience of studying them or referring to them, but are absolutely in constant danger of being swept away from amongst us by the merest accident, or of being destroyed by natural decay from the impossibility of properly preserving them. Had we a building suitable for a Library and Museum, in which scientific works and scientific collections and instruments could be deposited, we could, in addition to our existing treasures being safely kept, have, to my certain knowledge, several hundreds of volumes made accessible to students, and some thousands of specimens in various branches of science placed under their observation. It is to me lamentable to think that all these treasures should be locked up in the hands of and accessible only to a few, when, by a little exertion, we might render them accessible to all, by providing a building in which they would be safe and properly cared for. Such a state of things ought not to be in a community so large and so wealthy as this, and I trust it will not long be allowed to continue. For the sake of science, which we profess to love—for the sake of our society—for the sake of our successors—for the sake of our own credit and the credit of our Province—an effort, and a very strenuous effort, ought to be made by us to found, in some shape or way, a free public library and museum. We are possessed (thanks to the goodwill of my predecessor in office, as Superintendent) of an excellent and valuable site for such a building. The building is what we want. We cannot expect our Provincial Government, in its impoverished condition, to aid us to any considerable extent, as has been done to our sister societies in the South by their Provincial Governments, out of their plethoric land funds. We can hope for nothing from the General Government, for all that can with difficulty be squeezed out of the common purse is needed for (and, I will add, well spent in) the maintenance of the central institution at Wellington. We must, therefore, rely on our own energies, resources, and liberality. I would, therefore, invite some of our members to contribute designs for a suitable building, to

cost, say, from £2,000 to £3,000; and I would further invite others of our members to contribute various practical detailed plans by which the necessary amount might be raised. That it can be done I am convinced, if we only go earnestly and determinedly about it. We have, in fact, only to raise £1,000 in cash in order to obtain the remaining £2,000 at £120 per annum of interest, which, I believe, we could easily realize from rents of class rooms, lecture rooms, and proceeds of lectures, without interfering with the ordinary revenue of the society. Or we might, by combining with some kindred institution and uniting our forces, raise the entire sum required. I press this earnestly on your attention, for I believe that the present state of our Library and Museum has been a great hindrance to us in the past, and that a better state of these would be an immense impetus to us for the future.
In connection with the past of our own and kindred societies, permit me to invite your attention to the fifth volume of the Transactions and Proceedings of the New Zealand Institute, just published. In quantity and in quality it is equal, if not superior, to its predecessors, although I venture to think that it might be somewhat abridged without loss to science or loss of interest to general readers. There are eighteen papers on miscellaneous subjects, the first of which, on “The Life and Times of Te Rauperaha,” will be found exceedingly interesting. There are nineteen zoological papers, some of them, in regard to the birds of New Zealand, of special interest; thirteen botanical papers, in which our worthy secretary stands pre-eminent; five chemical papers, all by Mr. Skey, of the Wellington Laboratory; and two geological papers, besides a summary of the proceedings of the various affiliated societies. It strikes me that chemistry and geology are, though ably, not so extensively represented as they might be if the votaries of these respective branches of science were to favour us with their contributions. And the absence of geographical and biological papers seems to me somewhat remarkable. The absence of biological papers may, no doubt, be fairly attributed to the hesitation which thinkers and observers on such subjects must naturally have in laying their thoughts and observations before the public in the present unsettled state of that branch of science; and yet that is just the state in which stray thoughts and observations may prove to be of the greatest value. The absence of geographical papers is less easily accounted for; for if there be one branch of elementary knowledge more than another in which we are defective in New Zealand, it is that of the geographical knowledge of our own colony. We have two, I think, small school books purporting to be geographies of New Zealand, but both miserably defective even where not positively erroneous. Our children are drilled into British geography rather than into that of their own native country, New Zealand. We find our newspaper editors constantly displaying the grossest ignorance of the geography of the colony, and they have no reliable book of

reference to guide them. Here, I think, is a department in which many of our members could give valuable contributions, which ere long could be built up into an authoritative and reliable geography of New Zealand.
It must, I think, be pleasing to you, as it is to me, to observe that—whether owing to the influence of our own and kindred societies or not I will not venture to assert—physical science is becoming rapidly recognized as a subject of even elementary education in the colony. Not only have we in the Otago University a Professor of Natural Science of no mean rank, but is several of the educational establishments affiliated to the New, Zealand University there are lecturers on chemistry, botany, and other branches of physics. And it is pleasing to observe that popular lectures in some of our towns on scientific subjects are attracting attention and drawing audiences. These things point to the progress of the future, when the dry bones of history and thrice-threshed straw of logic and philosophy will give place to the study of things capable of proof—of physical science.
But here I desire to remind you and the public that we are not merely a scientific society. The terms “science” and “scientific” have become so much words of terror to those who fancy themselves outside of the pale that they either, on the one hand, hate or fear us as antagonists, or pooh-pooh us as enthusiasts. From their ranks, as well as from yours, I desire to enlist contributors to our proceedings, by reminding you that we are an artistic and literary, as well as a scientific, society. Science is of things we know—the provable; it deals with with what is cognizable by our senses or demonstrable to them, and with the deductions that may either necessarily or probably be fairly derivable from these facts, observable by, or demonstrable to, our senses. But man is not all sense, however much his other capacities may owe to or be dependent upon his perceptive faculties. Whether his mental powers or æsthetic feelings be or be not independent of his physical nature in their origin, we must recognize the fact that in many the pure mental or literary powers, in many others the æsthetic or artistic feelings, largely predominate over the purely scientific faculty—the desire to know and the capacity of knowing. And we must further recognize the fact that there is an influence, and a very beneficial influence, exerted upon the scientific tendency by the, to some extent, divergent literary and artistic tendency. As Professor Tyndall has so well pointed out, there is a great scientific use of the imagination—“that wondrous faculty, which, left to ramble uncontrolled, leads us astray into a wilderness of perplexities and errors, a land of mists and shadows; but which, properly controlled by experience and reflection, becomes the noblest attribute of man—the source of poetic genius, the instrument of discovery in science, without the aid of which Newton would never have invented fluxions, nor Davy have decomposed the earths and alkalies, nor would Columbus have

found another continent.” So, also, of the artistic feelings—the love of harmony and the beautiful—they have a real scientific value. The popular collocation of art, science, and literature has more real substantial basis than we might be inclined at first sight to award it. In fact, like the popular instinct for beans and bacon, peas and pork, potatoes and beef, which Liebig shows to have certain real relative nutritive values, so the popular instinct which associates art, science, and literature unconsciously recognizes the fact that these have re-operative influences on each other, and that neither alone can well attain to perfection or develop its entire mental nutritive value without the other.
I therefore desire to remind you that literary or artistic contributions are not foreign to the aims of our society, that, indeed, they would tend to increase the interest in it, and relieve it from the opprobrium of dealing exclusively with what, to many minds, seem dry, dull things—namely, facts. Thus, I think, contributions relative to the mythology of the native race; anecdotes relative to the early settlement of the colony, or of those who took part in that great colonizing work; reviews of such works as Darwin's “Descent of Man,” or his “Emotions,” Maudsley on “Mind” and “Body and Mind,” Bastian's “Beginnings of Life,” Brassey's “Work and Wages”; or of such as Domett's “Ranolf and Amohia,” the Earl of Pembroke's “South Sea Bubbles,” Trollope's “Australia and New Zealand,” or criticisms on the works of our New Zealand artists, suggestions for beautifying our domains or for utilizing our natural products, these and many other subjects would, I think, come within the scope of our society's constitution, and impart an interest and popularity to our proceedings. Not that I would court a popularity which would impair, but only that which might enhance our usefulness. For there is a solid value in popularity when allied to usefulness, although by itself it is a worthless element, and, when allied to that which is useless, even a mischievous thing. But believing, as I do most sincerely, that we are in this society doing quietly and unassumingly a good work for the community at large, we cannot, I think, too much endeavour to render our work and our objects popular as well as useful. It is one of the characteristics of the science of the present age, that it endeavours to make itself popular—that is, known to, understood by, and liked by, the mass of the people. We find that the profoundest scientific minds think it not beneath them to endeavour—as Tyndall, Huxley, and others do and have done—to educate the minds and enlist the sympathies of the people in and in favour of the great truths which physical science teaches; I say the truths which it teaches, for herein lies the grand power of physical science—its confidence in truth, its utter hatred of all that is untrue; its unwillingness to admit as truth that which is only a probability; its doubt and distrust of what is only a

possibility. And, feeling in itself, the power and necessity of truth, the scientific mind accepts no authority and subscribes to no faith which it cannot if necessary test and verify; whilst, on the other hand, it asks no acceptance for its own conclusions without their being thoroughly tested, both as to the reality of the facts on which they are based and the legitimacy of the conclusions themselves. What the ultimate conclusions may be we know not, and fear not, confident in this—that if true scientific processes be employed to test them, they must be either true, or the nearest approach to truth that we mortals can hope to attain to.
I thank you for your patience, and bespeak your indulgence for the hurried thoughts I have this evening placed before you.
1. “On the Geological Structure of the Thames Gold Fields,” by Captain F. W. Hutton, F.G.S. (Transactions, p. 272.)
Report on, and Analysis of, the Water with which it is proposed to supply Shortland and Grahamstown. From the Colonial Laboratory, was communicated by His Honour the Superintendent
2. The following Report on, and Analysis of, the Water with which it is proposed to supply Shortland and Grahamstown, forwarded by Dr. Hector from the Colonial Laboratory, was communicated by His Honour the Superintendent:—
“27th May, 1873.—Character of Water.—Clear, tasteless; a slight sediment had formed, the character of which was not examined. The water, separated from this and analyzed, gave the following results, calculated upon a gallon of it:
[The section below cannot be correctly rendered as it contains complex formatting. See the image of the page for a more accurate rendering.]
| “Chlorine | 1.551 |
| “Sulphuric acid | .354 |
| “Carbonic acid | 1.783 |
| “Magnesia | .665 |
| “Lime | .308 |
| “Soda and potash | 2.772 |
| “Silica | 2.857 |
| 10.290 |
“Organic matter—the average of two determinations—2.1 grains per gallon.
“Amount of readily oxidizable matters per gallon, .384 grains.
“The bottles enclosing samples being closed with corks, instead of glass, as should always be done, the results have not that degree of value they would otherwise have.
“The quantity of readily oxidizable organic matter is probably a little too high, as here given, owing to the presence of a little sulphuretted hydrogen in the water tested, from the cork having deoxidized a portion of the sulphuric acid present in the water, and for this reason the quantity of this acid, as stated in results, will be less than it really is.
“However, subject to these errors, the water proves to be of fair quality, but inferior to some waters for brewing purposes, owing to a deficiency of lime salts.”

Third Meeting. 4th August, 1873.
The Hon. Colonel Haultain in the chair.
New members.—H. Brett, J. Breen, B.A., Capt. Steel, J. Watt, H. Allwright, C.E., E. Waddington, M.D., G. Holdship, W. H. Kissling, R. Day, M.D., R. Millett, C.E., W. H. Clarke, H. Richmond, T. Kissling, J. Fairburn.
The Secretary read the list of donations to the Library and Museum.
The Secretary exhibited a specimen of damask table cloth woven from native-dressed Phormium, and read an extract of a letter from the Agent-General in England relative thereto.
Mr. D. Hay exhibited cones of Pinus radiata and P. insignis grown in the vicinity of Auckland, and made a few observations on the trees which produced them.
Mr. Kirk offered a few remarks on Captain Hutton's paper on the Geological Structure of the Thames Gold Fields, read at the last meeting.
Remarks were made by various members on the Analysis of Thames Water Supply, read at previous meeting.
1. “On the New Zealand Forms of Cheilanthes,” by T. Kirk, F.L.S. (Transactions, p. 247.)
The paper was illustrated by specimens from the Herbarium of the Auckland Institute.
Remarks on Dr. Bastian's recent work on the Beginnings of Life,
2. “Remarks on Dr. Bastian's recent work on the Beginnings of Life,” by T. Heale.
(Abstract.)
After giving an historical notice of the subject, the paper epitomized, at some length, the views maintained by Dr. Bastian as to the identity of vital force and ordinary physical force, and the impossibility of maintaining any sharp line of distinction between organic and inorganic matter; described the nature of colloids, and the behaviour of crystallizable substances in viscid fluids, as investigated by Mr. Rainey and Mr. Lewes, which showed how very similar some of the products of undoubted crystallizing forces may be to some of these formations from organic matter which are considered to be living organisms. The writer observed that it would be presumption to set up independent opinions here on such a subject; that we must wait till the “masters have spoken”; but, as a provisional hypothesis, the view forcibly struck him that since there must be a point in the chain of creatures above which life is only produced by germs or ova, this distinction must establish so sharp a line of division that it may be open to doubt whether the lower one should be considered as living at all. He noticed a great apparent want of continuity

in Dr. Bastian's experiments and reasoning: he had shown that Bacteria, occasionally forming films, were produced in his solutions boiled in vacuum tubes; and he then went on to show, with admirable clearness, the progress of development of higher organisms from Bacterian and Leptothrix films when placed in ordinary conditions. But he does not, as far as the writer can see, anywhere maintain that the films formed by him as described, in vacuo, will produce penecilium, euglenæ or paramecia, and ciliated infusoria, if only exposed to air which has been effectually deprived of germs; whence it might be inferred that Dr. Bastian admits the necessity of germs for these.
The paper quoted at length Professor Wyville Thomson's remarks upon the very lowest form of life, Bathybius, spread in an almost unbroken sheet under the whole area of the ocean, and suggested that this vast development of protoplasm everywhere—in every stagnant ditch, or under 15,000 feet of ocean—may be but the first link between organized creatures and inorganic matter, necessary to the existence and development of life, and consisting of very compound and, therefore, mobile molecules, built up by physical forces, and, though subject to very great and rapid changes, being in a constant condition of variation and molecular motion, yet not itself alive.
The paper went on to notice the great apparent difficulty, suggested by Dr. Bastian, in conceiving that these lower forms of life should have descended, from a line of ancestry far more remote than any of the higher animals, and should still be as simple and rudimentary as at first; facts which he considers quite opposed to the principles of the Uniformitarian and Evolutionary Philosophy. It was maintained that, while the conditions remained such as could only maintain the most rudimentary forms of life, development must remain an impossibility; that when the conditions admitted of a higher form of life being maintained, there development had probably taken place.
The paper wound up with a few short observations on the importance of this subject, not for scientific purposes only, but as largely influencing the issues of health and disease, and a hope that the colonists of New Zealand would never so alienate themselves from the rest of the human family as to consider so vast a human interest foreign to them.
An interesting discussion ensued, in which many members took part.
Fourth Meeting. 8th September, 1873.
The Rev. A. G. Purchas, M.R.C.S.E., in the chair.
The list of donations to the Library and Museum was read by the Secretary.
On Cosmography.
1. “On Cosmography,” by J. Leith.

2. “On the Reclamation of Sand-wastes on the Coast, and the Prevention of their Inland Advance,” by J. Stewart, C.E. (Transactions, p. 42.)
Remarks on the paper were made by Messrs. Mitford, Kirk, and others.
On Induction and Necessary Truth
3. “On Induction and Necessary Truth,” by the Rev. R. Kidd, LL.D.
Fifth Meeting. 6th October, 1873.
The Hon. Colonel Haultain in the chair.
New members.—J. Wallace, J. Goodall, C.E., H. T. Kemp.
The list of donations to the Library and Museum was read by the Secretary.
A letter was read from Mr. Leith relative to his paper on Cosmography, read at the previous meeting.
Remarks on Mr. Leith's paper on Cosmography,”
1. “Remarks on Mr. Leith's paper on Cosmography,” by T. Heale.
Dr. Kidd, Mr. Pond, and others spoke on the subject.
2. “On the most Economic Mode of Felting Steam Boilers,” by J. C. Firth. (Transactions, p. 32.)
The paper was illustrated by a diagram and model. Messrs. Stewart, C.E., Lodder, Chamberlin, and others spoke in terms of commendation of the simplicity and efficiency of the plan brought forward.
3. “Notes on the Plants best adapted for the Reclamation of Sand-wastes,” by T. Kirk, F.L.S. (Transactions, p. 45.)
A long and interesting discussion ensued, in which Messrs. Mair, Stewart, Firth, Knorpp, Hay, Goodall, and others took part.
Sixth Meeting. 10th November, 1873.
The Rev. A. G. Purchas, M.R.C.S.E., in the chair.
New members.—His Excellency Sir James Fergusson, Bart., J. Martin, Major Green, S. B. Biss, J. F. Slowman, W. Drake, R. Whitson, C. E. Cook.
The Secretary read the list of donations to the Library and Museum.
Report on Samples of Stone from the Tokatea Tunnel, was communicated by His Honour the Superintendent
1. The following Report on Samples of Stone from the Tokatea Tunnel, by Dr. Hector, was communicated by His Honour the Superintendent:—
“11th October, 1873.—On the 11th July, I learn from Mr. Aitken's letter and plan, that the length of the drive, which runs north-east and south-west, was on the west, or Coromandel side, 750 feet; and on the east, or Kennedy Bay side, 250 feet, making a total of 1,000 feet, or about half the total distance which has to be driven. The drive is divided into sections of 100 feet in

length, and from each, what I presume to be an average specimen of the rock passed through, has been sent, together with samples of the reefs cut.
-
“1st Section on West Side.—A dark, very compact base, containing tabular crystals of felspar, and grains of a red mineral not determined. The structure is only visible in the heart of the fragments, which are weathered on the outside, of a mottled green, and dirty from earth.
-
“2nd Section.—Soft rock of a light buff colour, mottled as if formed by the decomposition of a felspathic paste, containing an imperfectly crystallized mineral.
-
“3rd Section.—Fine-grained breccia containing rolled pebbles of the tufanite rock in the 4th and 5th sections, and iron pyrites in small quantity; evidently a rock that has been decomposed.
-
“4th Section.—Compact white paste, speckled with blue spots, that have no defined shape, and containing much pyrites.
-
“5th Section.—Sharp granular rock of light grey colour, containing large quantities of pyrites in brilliant crystals and grains. This is the characteristic tufanite of the Thames Gold Fields.
“In this rock the first quartz vein was met with, lying very flat, the dip being 22° to south-south-east. Its thickness on the plan is stated to be 1 foot 6 inches, and its yield 19 dwts. per ton.
“The sample sent of the quartz from this vein showed distinct traces of gold, but the quantity was too small to be determined.
-
“6th Section.—Dark coloured, compact, heavy rock, containing much carbonate of lime and pyrites.
“This section is cut through at 560 feet by a quartz vein 6 inches thick, running north and south, with an easterly dip of 25°. The quartz is stated to yield 6 ozs. 10 dwts., but the sample received only gave traces of gold. After a short interval there is a second vein, 1 foot thick, with nearly the same dip, resting on a dyke said to be diorite, but no sample seems to have been sent. The vein-stone is calcspar, with druses lined with crystals of arragonite, and only containing small threads of quartz.
-
“7th Section.—Light coloured, calcareous, and pyritous rock. This is cut by a quartz vein 6 feet thick, and nearly flat, or with a slight underlay of one in twenty to east. The quartz is crystalline, and the sample sent gave at the rate of 25 grains per ton of gold.
“In the 8th section, at 720 feet, a small vein of similar size, and underlying, was cut, the sample of which only gave traces of gold. It is noticed that on cutting this vein a heavy flow of water was met.
“The rock where the tunnel had reached to from the west side, in June, was compact, granular, and of a dark grey colour, charged with pyrites, and only feebly calcareous.

“On the Kennedy Bay side—1st Section is a coarse granular, or sub-crystalline rock, light in colour, and containing pyrites, but weathering freely to a dark brown. On the west side of this band of rock are two quartz veins, 5 and 3 inches respectively, trending north-east, and underlying to the west at 20°.
“The samples of these sent gave at the rate of 28 grains per ton of gold.
-
“2nd Section and 3rd Section.—Very compact felstone, or indurated claystone full of pyrites in large masses and crystals.
“A glance at the suite of specimens submitted shows that, while there is considerable variety in the rocks cut through in the tunnel, after passing the 3rd section of 300 feet from the west end they all belong to the same group. The presence of carbonate of lime in large quantities, both as a constituent of the hardest and densest parts of the rock, and as secondary deposits in veins, is very interesting, and shows that, even if these rocks had at first a volcanic origin, as has been supposed, they have since undergone much alteration. The marked change at 300 feet, and the presence in the rock at section 3 of rolled fragments of the more interior rock, is sufficient proof of the existence of two formations belonging to different periods.
“All the rocks will be exhaustively analyzed and microscopically examined, so that the fullest benefit to science may be obtained from this most interesting work.”
2. “On the Probability of a Water Supply being obtained for the City of Auckland from Mount Eden,” by J. Goodall, C.E. (Transactions, p. 35.)
An animated discussion ensued.
3. “On the Prediction of Occultations of Stars by the Moon,” by T. Heale, C.E. (Transactions, p. 57.)
Mr. T. B. Gillies was chosen to vote in the election of the Board of Governors for the ensuing year, in accordance with Clause 7 of the New Zealand Institute Act.
Seventh Meeting. 8th December, 1873.
New members.—Sir G. A. Arney, Chief Justice of New Zealand, T. Spencer, G. F. Edmonstone, A. Clark, J. E. Allen, J. Robertson.
The Secretary read the list of donations to the Library and Museum.
The Secretary stated that a complete set of rock specimens from the Tokatea Tunnel would eventually be placed in the Museum.
1. “On the Probability of a Water Supply being obtained for the City of Auckland from Mount Eden” (continued), by J. Goodall, C.E. (Transactions, p. 39.)

2. “Notes on the Proposition to supply Auckland with Water from Mount Eden,” by J. Stewart, C.E. (Transactions, p. 40.)
This paper was read by the Secretary in the absence of the author.
A lengthy and animated discussion ensued, in which Mr. Baber, C.E., advocated Mr. Goodall's proposal, which was not received with favour by the majority of members who spoke on the subject.
3. “Notice of an Undescribed Species of Cordyline (C. hookeri),” by T. Kirk, F.L.S. (Transactions, p. 244.)
The paper was illustrated by specimens from the Herbarium of the Institute.
4. “Notes on Indigenous Materials for the Manufacture of Paper,” by T. Kirk, F.L.S. (Transactions, p. 55.)
Recent specimens of most of the plants named were exhibited by the author.
Mr. Heale drew the attention of the members to the approaching removal of the Secretary to Wellington, and, after eulogizing his services to the Institute, proposed that the thanks of the members be presented to Mr. Kirk, with the expression of their cordial good wishes for his prosperity.
The proposition was seconded by the Rev. A. G. Purchas, supported by the President, and carried.
In expressing his sense of the honour conferred upon him, Mr. Kirk stated that, notwithstanding the trials through which the Institute had passed during the six years of its existence, it had never retrograded, but always maintained its position as the first, in point of number, of all the affiliated societies of the New Zealand Institute.
Annual General Meeting. 16th February, 1874.
T. B. Gillies, President, in the chair.
New members.—George Ranger, E. Hesketh.
The list of donations to the Library and Museum during the past month was read by the Secretary.
Abstract Report of the Council.
The number of new members was greater than in any previous year. During the year seven meetings were held and seventeen papers read.
Numerous and valuable donations have been made to the Museum and Library, and specially by Mr. Kirk, F.L.S., of wood sections, New Zealand shells, a collection of British ferns, and other valuable additions.
The Council regret the very inadequate space at their disposal, and the

unsuitable buildings for the Museum and Library, and hope that means may be devised for providing the accommodation so urgently required.
They note the resignation of the Secretary, Mr. T. Kirk, F.L.S., and desire to record their appreciation of his services to the Institute during the last six years. But for his unwearied exertions and constant attention to the affairs of the society, it could not have attained its present amount of success. The Council feel that his removal will be a serious loss, not only to the Institute, but also to the Province.
The receipts for the year amounted to £333 6s. 3d., and the expenditure to £215 17s. 5d., leaving a balance of £117 8s. 10d., of which £10 3s. 10d. is carried to Building Fund and Investment Account. The entrance fees and subscriptions amounted to £232 1s., and the sum of £83 4s. 7d. had been spent in books and additions to the Museum.
Election of Officers for 1874
Election of Officers for 1874.—President—Chief Justice Sir George A. Arney; Council—J. L. Campbell, M.D., J. C. Firth, T. B. Gillies, J. Goodall, C.E., D. Hay, Hon. Col. Haultain, Rev. J. Kinder, D.D., Rev. A. G. Purchas, M.R.C.S.E., J. Stewart, C.E., T. F. S. Tinne, T. Heale; Auditor—C. Tothill; Secretary—T. F. Cheeseman.
The President informed the members that steps were being taken to present Mr. Kirk, their late Secretary, with a substantial recognition of his services. Mr. Kirk had not been an ordinary Secretary. He had contributed largely, not only in papers, but also in specimens to the Museum and books to the Library.
The Rev. Dr. Purchas spoke in terms of praise of Mr. Kirk, and of the value of his services to the society as a scientific man of a high order and of a European reputation.
Considerable discussion took place on the urgent necessity existing for increased accommodation for the Library and Museum, and it was resolved that the Council be recommended to appoint a sub-committee especially to attend to the subject.
Resolved—That a vote of thanks be given to the President, Council, and Office-bearers of the society for their services during the past year, and that the same be recorded on the minutes of the Institute.
