Go to National Library of New Zealand Te Puna Mātauranga o Aotearoa
Volume 40, 1907
This text is also available in PDF
(792 KB) Opens in new window
– 110 –

Art. X.—The Scheelite of Otago.

[Read before the Otago Institute, 8th October, 1907.]

Plate XVI.

Scheelite occurs in greater or less quantity in a large number of the auriferous-quartz veins in the Otago goldfields. The country rock of the veins is for the most part a quartzose micaschist, graduating into phyllite and slate. It is included in Sir James Hector's “foliated schists,”* and in the Wanaka and Kakanui series of the late Captain Hutton.†

Only those veins which carry scheelite in exploitable quantity will here be considered, and these may be conveniently grouped into two classes—(1) fissure-veins; (2) bedded or segregated veins. The latter occur exclusively in the Macrae's district; the former class includes all other known scheelite-veins.

(1.) Fissure-Veins.
Glenorchy Reef.

This outcrops on the steep left bank of the Bucklerburn, a mile and a half above its mouth at Glenorchy. The country rock is a slate, striking north and south, and dipping to the west at from 30° to 50°. The vein strikes east and west, and dips to the north at a mean angle of 15°. It has been followed on the surface for about half a mile, is well defined, with fairly smooth walls, and carries a strong continuous seam of quartz throughout. Its width between walls varies from 1ft. to 5ft.

In accordance with the varying width of the walls, the vein is lenticular in longitudinal section, a feature which evidently indicates some displacement of the walls of the original fissure (fig. 1).

Picture icon

Fig. 1.

[Footnote] * Sir J. Hector, “Outline of New Zealand Geology” (1886), p. 83.

[Footnote] †Captain F. W. Hutton, “Geology of Otago” Dunedin, 1875), p. 29.

– 111 –

The accompanying sketch section (fig. 2), along No. 2 level, illustrates this feature.

Picture icon

Fig. 2.—Section Along No. 2 Level, Glenorchy Reef.

The seam of quartz generally occupies the centre of the lode-formation, being separated from the walls by a few inches of pug. Frequently, however, the seam splits into two branches, leaving a horse of country rock between (fig. 3).

Picture icon

Fig. 3.

The quartz is seamed throughout with thin parallel strings of mullock, highly pyritized.

The reef carries scheelite, not generally in very clean patches, but more or less quartzose. It does not cling particularly to either wall, but is generally seen along mullock stringers. The bands or seams of scheelite, though discontinuous, are fairly well defined. The lode is auriferous, but its assay value for gold is very small.

Recent prospecting in the Rees Valley and Bucklerburn has disclosed other reefs carrying scheelite, some of which are now being developed.

Alta Reef, Bendigo.

This lies at the head of a small gully just over the western spur of Bendigo Creek, and about three miles to the east of the old Bendigo battery. Its strike is 116°, and it stands almost vertically, with frequent irregularities. The country rock is a flat-lying quartzose schist, and the outcrop of the reef has been proved for nearly half a mile.

– 112 –

Near the east end of the old workings the vein is thin and the seam of quartz insignificant. Followed west, it increases in width, and has a sinuous and irregular course, with numerous leaders coming in on both walls. The accompanying sketches (figs. 4 and 5) illustrate the characters of the vein.

Picture icon

Fig. 4.—Section Across Alta Reef.

Picture icon

Fig. 5.—Section Across Alta Reef.

Near the end of an adit driven close to the old battery-site scheelite is seen in conspicuous bunches on and near the south wall, which is here poorly defined (fig. 6).

Picture icon

Fig. 6.

The scheelite in this reef has never been exploited, but the reef was successfully worked for gold in the early days.

Veins on the Lammerlaw Range, Waipori.

Several of the small gold-bearing veins on the Lammerlaw and Burnt Ranges, near Waipori, carry scheelite, sometimes in considerable quantity, but they have never been developed to any extent.

A notable occurrence of the mineral is in the antimony-reef at Stony Creek, nine miles from Waipori Township. At one point in this reef scheelite and stibnite were found in close association, and accompanied by gypsum. This last is evidently a product of secondary origin, resulting from oxidation of the sulphide ore and interaction with the scheelite.

Among other occurrences, scheelite has been found in the Barewood reef, and in the Saddle Hill reef.

(2.) Bedded Veins.

The reefs of Macrae's are bedded or segregated veins, and are of peculiar interest in that they embrace all the veins of this

– 113 –

class in Otago. The Macrae's goldfield occupies an area of two hundred square miles between Dunback and the Taieri River, and extending from the Mareburn in the north to the Stoneburn in the south.

The country rock is an argillaceous mica-schist, with much interfoliated quartz. With few exceptions, it has throughout the area a uniform strike—north-west and south-east—and a north-easterly dip of from 10° to 20°. The veins consequently all have that dip, allowance being made for local irregularities.

A description of the features to be seen in Messrs. W. and G. Donaldson's mines will sufficiently illustrate the characters of the veins.

Donaldson's Reef, Mount Highlay.

This outcrops 10 chains up the hill to the west of a small creek running north to the Mareburn. The hanging-wall is very ill defined, and for a distance of 40 ft. beyond the wall the country rock is impregnated with pyrite, and crossed by frequent slides. Near the hanging-wall a few lenticular bunches of segregated quartz appear.

The vein, near its outcrop, is cut by a north-south fault, which has dragged it down in a very striking manner, and open-cast work along the fault-line displays a good section (fig. 7). Both walls are here smooth and slickensided, as a result of the faulting, and the hanging-wall country is much twisted and broken.

Picture icon

Fig. 7—Section Across Donaldson's Lode, at Fault-Line

Followed west up the flank of the hill, the foot-wall continues well defined, with a varying seam of quartz, but the hanging-wall loses its individuality, the lode-material grading off into crushed and veined country rock.

The reef carries from 10 dwt. to 15 dwt. of gold per ton, and scheelite in places.

Golden Point Reef.

This outcrops on the right bank of the Deep Dell, directly south of Mount Highlay. It has a mean north-easterly dip

– 114 –

of 10°, and has been opened up by a considerable amount of tunnelling.

In general, the reef varies in thickness from 1 ft. to over 6 ft., its mean width being 3 ft. The foot-wall is generally smooth and fairly defined, the hanging-wall indistinct. As in the Glenorchy reef, and from the same cause, frequent rolls occur, illustrated in the section (fig. 8).

Picture icon

Fig. 8.—Longitudinal Sketoh Section, Golden Point Reef.

The quartz occurs in a seam from 6 in. to 4 ft. thick, the remainder of the lode-formation being composed of soft structureless pug, graduating into veined and crushed country rock, and crossed by frequent slides. The seam generally follows the foot-wall, but sometimes divides into two, one on each wall. It occasionally crosses from one wall to the other, and a seam may wedge out on one wall, while another comes in on the other wall immediately opposite.

The Ounce Reef.

This lies four miles south-east from Macrae's Township, on the left bank of a small stream running into Murphy's Creek. The outcrop of the reef is anticlinal, due to a local rock-fold, and the vein peters out on the limbs of the anticline (fig. 9).

Picture icon

Fig. 9.—Section, Ounce Reef.

It thus simulates the saddle-reef type of Bendigo, Victoria.

Several other outcrops in the Macrae's and Mount Highlay districts have been prospected and intermittently worked for gold, but nearly every one that has been developed has been found to carry more or less scheelite. The gold-value of the lodes varies from 4 dwt. to 12 dwt., mostly free-milling.

– 115 –

It is significant that all the reefs in this district outcrop on a single plane in the schist. This indicates that the horizontal shearing movement which localised the reefs followed a particular zone in the rock, although it is quite likely that there may be one or more zones or levels of lode-formation beneath the one now exposed.

(3.) The Scheelite.

This mineral occurs, firstly, in segregated masses of varying size, typically seen at Macrae's. These generally cling to the foot-wall, and frequently pass right into the country rock, the foot-wall being then obscured. These comparatively pure masses grade off into highly quartzose ore scattered through the gangue. Secondly, it occurs in irregular veins in the quartz leaders and stringers, as well as in the larger quartz seams. It may constitute a whole vein, or it may have a broad or narrow selvage of quartz on either side.

The hand-specimen, which always contains some quartz, has a specific gravity of 5.12, that of the pure mineral being 5.9 to 6.1 (Dana). It is yellowish-white in colour, brittle and friable, with an irregular fracture. It shows interrupted cleavagesurfaces, and is massive in habit, no crystals being found, as far as my observations showed.

Microscopic Characters.

In section (Plate XVI, a, b), the mineral is dark-brown, with a high refractive index. In isotropic sections a faint positive uniaxial figure may be seen. The interference colours are more usually yellow and red of the first order. The individuals are large, with sharp boundaries and pointed or pyramidal terminations. Two interrupted sets of cleavage-traces crossing at 40° are seen in suitable sections, these being the characteristic cleavages, p (111) and e (101). The cleavage-lines are frequently crossed by irregular fractures, along which the mineral is dark and clouded. A faint lamellar structure is occasionally seen, resembling polysynthetic twinning. The lamellæ, however, are alternately broad and narrow, and can be distinguished, though with difficulty, in ordinary light. The appearance is probably a strain-effect.

Chemical Composition.

The following analysis indicates the average composition of Otago scheelite. Quartz is always present in intimate association, as shown in Plate XVI, a and b; in the analysis this constituent was eliminated, and the figures recalculated to 100 per cent.

– 116 –
Per Cent.
WO3 80.58
CaO 18.98
MgO 0.20
FeO 0.24
Fe2O3 Nil.
MnO Nil.
CO2 Nil.
———
100.00

The FeO and MgO are probably present as isomorphous tungstates, and the mineral composition is then as follows:—

Per Cent.
CaWO4 97.63
FeWO4 1.01
MgWO4 1.36
——
100.00

The commercial scheelite of Otago is thus not the pure calcium compound. The absence of manganese indicates that there is no admixture of wolfram.

The mineral carries distinct traces of molybdenum in varying quantities up to 1 per cent. The methods used in estimating this constituent were those of Rose,* of Ruegenberg and Smith,† and of Ibbotson and Brearley. A search was made for cerium and the other rare earths, both chemically and spectroscopically, but with negative results.

Analyses by Traube§ of scheelite from various localities are here inserted for reference and comparison, and the universal association of molybdenum is of peculiar interest. In his figures for New Zealand scheelite, it will be observed that he records no iron and no magnesia, but the particular locality from which his samples were collected is not recorded.

Locality. G. WO3. MoO3. CaO.
Zinnwald 5.88 71.08 8.23 20.33
" 6.03 75.29 3.98 20.34
" 6.01 76.78 3.69 19.86
" 6.03 77.84 2.23 19.48
" 6.06 78.04 1.92 19.57
Altenberg 6.07 77.54 2.03 19.91

[Footnote] * H. Rose, Handbuch der Anal. Chemie (Sechte Auflage, 1871), p. 358.

[Footnote] † Ruegenberg and Smith, Journal Amer. Chem. Soc., vol. xxii, p. 772.

[Footnote] ‡ Ibbotson and Brearley, Journal Chem. Soc., 1900, Abstr. ii, p. 445.

[Footnote] § J. D. Dana, “System of Mineralogy,” 6th ed. (1896), p. 987.

– 117 –
Locality. G. WO3. MoO3. CaO.
Schwargenberg(a) 6.12 79.94 Tr. 19.57
"(a) 6.02 80.17 0.07 19.49
Schlackenwald 6.13 79.76 Tr. 19.67
Haslithal 6.14 80.16 Tr. 19.65
Traversella(b) 6.06 78.57 1.62 19.37
"(b) 6.04 79.68 0.76 19.29
Carrick Fels. 6.01 79.97 0.35 19.27
Pot Mine, South Africa(c) 5.96 70.57 8.09 20.05
" 71.59 7.63 20.51
Mount Ramsay, Tasmania 6.09 79.77 Tr. 19.65
New Zealand 6.01 80.29 Tr. 19.44
(a) MgO, trace. (b) Ce2O3, trace. (b) CuO, 0.34.

(4.) Deposition of the Scheelite.

Microscopic examination of the ore, and chemical analyses of the wall-rock of the veins, prove that the scheelite has been formed by metasomatic processes—namely, by combination of tungstic acid with lime-bearing minerals in the adjoining rock.

Microscopic Evidence.

The relations of scheelite and calcite, as seen under the microscope, are very striking. Plate XVI, c, shows scheelite in clear granules with fresh sharp boundaries enclosing a corroded core of calcite, and indicating the replacement process by which the ore has been formed. This phenomenon is best studied at Macrae's, where the country rock contains a considerable amount of calcite. In general, the scheelite is always fresh, the calcite where seen is much attacked and corroded. Several of the plates accompanying Mr. Lindgren's classic work on “Metasomatic Processes in Fissure-veins”* show very similar processes to that illustrated in the above plate.

A similar association of scheelite and calcite is occasionally seen in sections cut from Glenorchy ore. A characteristic feature of the Glenorchy mineral is the manner in which strings of pyrite occur along the border between scheelite and gangue (Plate XVI, d). The pyrite thus appears to have segregated along the line of most intense metasomatism. The process of osmosis, regarded by many authorities as the central factor in ore-deposition,† would evidently be equally favourable to the formation both of scheelite and of pyrite, the latter being, like the former, essentially a replacement product.

[Footnote] * “Genesis of Ore-deposits,” Trans. Amer. Inst. Min. Eng., 1901, p. 498.

[Footnote] †H. P. Gillette, “Osmosis as a Factor in Ore-formation,” Trans. Amer. Inst. Min. Eng., vol. xxxiv (1903), p. 710.

– 118 –

Chemical Evidence.

The following analyses show the nature and extent of wall-rock alteration at Glenorchy:—

1. 2. 3. 4.
H2O 2.42 2.71 2.17 —0.25
SiO2 56.68 52.49 42.00 —14.68
Al2O3 9.96 12.38 9.96
Fe2O3 5.92 6.12 4.97 —0.95
FeO 6.77 2.42 1.94 —4.83
CaO 9.96 6.58 5.26 —4.70
MgO 1.55 1.19 0.95 —0.60
K2O 2.86 5.82 4.62 + 1.76
Na2O 2.41 2.86 2.32 —0.09
MnO 0.21 0.12 0.10 —0.11
TiO2 0.56 0.48 0.40 —0.16
FeS2 Nil 5.61 4.48 + 4.48
CO2 Nil 1.25 1.00 + 1.00
—— —— —— ——
99.30 100.03 80.17 + 7.24
—26.37
—19.13
1.

Unaltered rock.

2.

Altered rock.

3.

Altered rock, recalculated on a basis of constant alumina.

4.

Gains and losses of altered rock.

The considerable loss of silica in the wall-rock is characteristic of the veins throughout Otago. The notable loss of lime and addition of carbon-dioxide and potash indicate that the mineralising solutions carried alkaline tungstates and carbonates. Reaction with the wall-rock resulted in the addition of carbon-dioxide, and in exchange between lime of the rock and potash of the solutions, with the formation of scheelite in the lode.

The next group of analyses indicates the processes at Macrae's (samples from Golden Point).

1. 2. 3. 4.
H2O 0.70 1.24 0.67 —0.03
SiO2 70.02 60.58 30.29 —39.73
Al2O3 5.67 11.34 5.67
Fe2O3 3.68 4.88 2.44 —1.18
FeO 3.38 2.56 1.28 —2.10
CaO 7.80 4.31 2.15 —5.65
Mgo 1.20 0.62 0.31 —0.89
K2O 0.78 3.01 1.50 + 0.72
Na2O 1.22 5.12 2.56 + 1.34
FeS2 Nil 4.27 2.13 + 2.13
CO2 6.42 2.92 1.46 —4.96
100.87 100.85 50.46 + 4.36
—54.71
—50.35
– 119 –
1.

Unaltered rock; specific gravity = 2.695.

2.

Altered rock; specific gravity = 2.693.

3.

Altered rock, recalculated on a basis of constant alumina.

4.

Gains and losses of altered rock.

In this case the loss of half the total mass of the rock, including 40 per cent. of the original rock, is in accordance with the fact that the Macrae's veins are segregated veins. In other words, wall-rock + lode (gangue) = original rock. This approximate equation will hold good for volumes as well as for masses—that is to say, the wall-rock has suffered a corresponding diminution of 50 per cent. in volume. This explains why the specific gravity of the altered rock (2.69) is equal to that of the unaltered rock.

Further, there is to be observed in the wall-rock a depletion of lime and addition of alkalies, as at Glenorchy, and likewise due to the processes by which the scheelite was deposited. The notable loss of carbon-dioxide is no doubt due to the destruction of calcite during the metasomatic action.

The bunchy tendency of the ore, particularly at Macrae's, is evidence of the segregation of the mineral during the formation of the lodes.

(5.)Genesis of New Zealand Tungsten-Ores.

J. D. Irving, in a description of the tungsten-deposits of the Black Hills of South Dakota,* deposits which occur in association with crystalline limestone, has divided tungsten-ore deposits into two classes:—

(1.) “Primary deposits,” associated with granitic rocks, in veins with cassiterite, and minerals such as tourmaline, beryl, and fluor-spar. Such were concentrated by the pneumatolytic phase of activity of the granitic magma.

(2.) “Secondary deposits,” formed by solution of bodies of the first type and metasomatic redeposition in higher levels.

The scheelite of Otago is thus a typical secondary deposit. As regards the other type, it is probable that the wolfram of Stewart Island, which has been described by Mr. Alex. McKay as occurring in the neighbourhood of granitic rocks, and in association with cassiterite, gahnite, and topaz, is a primary deposit as defined above.

Further, it is evident that the tungstic acid of the scheelite has ascended through the schists by way of the lode-fissures,

[Footnote] * J. D. Irving, “Wolframite in the Black Hills of South Dakota,” Trans. Amer. Inst. Min. Eng., vol. xxxi (1902), p. 683.

[Footnote] † A. McKay, “Reports of Geological Explorations, 1888–89,” p. 74.

– 120 –

and the fact that tungsten is a characteristic element in ore-deposits associated with granitic rocks leads to the inference that the magmas beneath were largely granitic in character.

(6.) The Scheelite-Mining Industry.

Rise and Progress.

The history of scheelite-mining in Otago dates from about 1888, when the first mine was opened up on the Glenorchy reef by the Lake Wakatipu Scheelite Company, and an expensive ore-dressing plant was installed. Some 27 tons of dressed ore was shipped to Hamburg, but the price was low—£20 to £29 per ton; and after two years the demand ceásed, and the company liquidated, after an outlay of £3,000.

About two years ago the mine was taken over by a new company, and a crushing and dressing plant installed. With a good market and improved methods of concentration, this company is making rapid strides.

On the Macrae's field scheelite was first exploited in 1893, by Messrs. A. B. Kitchener and William Donaldson, who sent 6 ½ tons of 40-per-cent. ore from the Golden Point Mine to London. The returns did not leave much profit, but the work was perserved with, and a later shipment realised £58 per ton. The market was subsequently transferred to Hamburg, and the demand and price steadily increased. Improved plant was installed, and considerable prospecting for scheelite was carried on, in consequence of the success attending Messrs. Donaldson's efforts. Up to date the Golden Point Mine has produced scheelite to the value of £24,000, the price having risen progressively in the last fifteen years from £20 to £160 per ton. During this period 400 tons of ore has been shipped from Macrae's while the Glenorchy Mine during the last eighteen months has dressed 60 tons.

Present Minning Methods.

There are at present three working mines—Messrs. Reid and Lee's Glenorchy Mine, and Messrs. W. and G. Donaldson's two mines at Macrae's. The method in vogue of concentrating the ore is to pass the pulp from the battery where it is crushed over shaking-tables or vanners, where it is dressed to an average value of 65 per cent. of tungstic acid (WO3), the impurities being quartz and pyrites. The ore thus concentrated is dried, bagged, and shipped.

For crushing the ore there are five stamps in operation at Glenorchy, ten at Golden Point, and a 5 ft. Huntington mill at

– 121 –

Mount Highlay. The concentrating-tables used are a Wilfley at Glenorchy and Mount Highlay, a Woodbury and Frue vanner at Golden Point. of these, the Wilfley appears to find most favour. The Glenorchy company have lately installed a Wilfley slime-table, with the object of recovering the slight loss in the tailings.

The pulp is dried over small wood or coke furnaces, a method that would scarcely be suitable for a large output. Further, a more efficient method of drying—or, rather, roasting—would burn off the sulphur of the pyrites, and thus indirectly raise the percentage value of the ore, which is a desideratum in view of the fact that the price per unit or per cent. varies with the percentage.

Prospects.

The success of the industry in Otago has been due to the steadily improving market at Hamburg, to which the ore is now shipped, and to greater attention on the part of present firms to the securing of clean and high-grade concentrates. The problem of concentration is a very important matter, as a poorly dressed ore will soon cause buyers to fight shy of the mine which ships it. The market, also, requires to be studied. In 1900, Messrs. G. P. Blackwell and Sons, metal-merchants, of Liverpool, reported thus: “The indiscriminate shipping of tungsten-ore from Australia and New Zealand is unwise, and has depressed the market, which is a peculiar one, and requires careful handling. Shippers should send their ore through one channel to a firm which understands the business, and can keep the market firm.”*

In view of the steadily increasing demand for tungsten, the prospects of the scheelite industry in Otago must be considered bright. Unfortunately, the fluctuations which have hitherto occurred in the market affect the production of small mines. This can only be guarded against by insuring that the mines shall be backed by sufficient capital, which would render them secure against closing down in the face of a slightly lowered quotation, an event which has happened more than once in New South Wales and Queensland.

Considering the success of the present producing mines, it is highly desirable that the other scheelite-veins, both in Otago and Marlborough, should be taken up, and there can be little doubt, provided the market remains firm, that they would prove successful ventures.

[Footnote] * New Zealand Mines Record, 16th November, 1900, p. 176.

– 122 –
Conclusion.

I must here express my indebtedness to Messrs. W. and G. Donaldson, of Macrae's, and Messrs. George Reid and Robert Lee, jun., of Glenorchy, for the many facilities and liberties they allowed me during my examination of the mines. To Dr. P. Marshall and Mr. D. B. Waters, of the Otago School of Mines, my warmest thanks are due for much valuable advice in the laboratory and in the preparation of this paper.

Explanation of Plate XVI.
a.

Section of scheelite, showing cleavage, and quartz (white). × 36 diameters.

b.

Scheelite, clouded, with quartz stringers. × 36 diameters.

c.

Illustrates metasomatic replacement. Dark fragments of scheelite, with calcite in the centre of the photograph. × 36 diameters.

d.

Scheelite (dark), separated from gangue (white) by strings of pyrite (black). The specimen was taken from Glenorchy. × 3 diameters.