
Art. XLI.—A Natural Classification of English Poetry.
[Read before the Philosophical Institute of Canterbury, 5th August, 1908.]
The discovery of the law guiding the formation of verse-lengths suggested in the paper on “Origins of English Metre,” read last session, has made it possible to scheme out a natural classification of the whole of English poetry.
For purposes of classification it is necessary to fix on some characteristic common to all species—a characteristic which, whilst it varies, does so in a regular manner, so that, whilst the characteristic itself is not perfectly constant, each variation is constant in itself. In poetry the problem has been to detect such a characteristic in the midst of an apparent maze of variations. One classification attempted has been according to quality— that is, all lyrics, including songs, odes, sonnets, have been grouped together; didactic poems, narrative, epic, dramatic, and so on: but this is similar to classifying flowers by their hues and scents. Again, another classification has been according to the number of stresses in a line as printed; so that one class included one-stressed or two-syllabled lines, another three-stressed, another four-stressed, and so on: this, too, is artificial, though it is nearer

the true classification: as in the system of Linnæus, the true organs have been taken, but classification has been by their number instead of by their development.
Under the breath-law, the various poetic forms in use group themselves into certain evident classes. This law indicated the first great characteristic —the length of line; and this gives two distinct classes—lines of five stresses and lines of eight stresses, each of which two classes I have named after their predominant types, Heroic and Ballad respectively. Setting aside the internal syllabic variation of verse, the places of greatest variation are at the beginning and end of lines. Variation at the end being the more pronounced, this has been taken as the distinguishing feature of the various ballad forms into which the Ballad class has been divided, and the variation at the beginning as the feature of the subvariations of the different forms. Thus in Romance Metre, or Parent Ballad, the line-end may lose a stress-unit, or foot, and become Popular Ballad, of seven instead of eight stresses. In the Popular Ballad, again, there are two variations—in one the stressed syllable at the end of every half-line is dropped, in the other the whole unit at the end of every half-line. These two forms would have been kept as subvariations of the Popular Ballad were it not for the fact that the former constitutes the normal ballad-metre of Denmark and Germany—and from the epic of the Nibelungen North being written in it I have called it the Nibelungen Metre—and the latter constitutes the ballad-metre of France, and has already been called the Alexandrine, from its forming the metre of a French epic on the deeds of Alexander.
The stress-unit at the beginning of the line can be varied only in two ways. In its normal form it consists of two syllables, the first unstressed, the second stressed. The unstressed syllable may be dropped, or it may be preceded by an extra unstressed syllable: from these variations are produced the subvariations in each of the Ballad forms.
Minor variations are formed by adding or dropping syllables at the line-ends. Thus, in Romance Metre an unstressed syllable may be added, when what is called a feminine or weak ending is produced. If it drop a syllable, it produces feminine Popular Ballad; if it drop two syllables, it produces ordinary Popular Ballad. If Popular Ballad, drop a syllable at the half-line end, it produces Nibelungen. If Nibelungen drop a syllable at the half-line end, it produces Alexandrine; if it add a syllable at the line - end, it produces either feminine Nibelungen or feminine Alexandrine.
Though these comprise the whole of the variations, except the internal syllabic variations which are rather to be considered as scent and colour, it will be seen that they include all regular formations outside lines of five stresses. These latter form the second great class, the Heroic. This does not show nearly the amount of variation of line-end shown by the former; its lines contain within themselves other and more subtle means of variation, such as pause, overflow, &c.—features practically denied to Ballad. Its subdivisions will be more readily seen. Firstly, the Common Heroic includes-all poems in riming couplets, with a subvariation including riming stanzas, such as Spenserian, Sonnet, Rime Royal, &c. Secondly, Blank Verse includes two divisions—Epic, Narrative, and Didactic poems; and the Drama, rimed or unrimed. A third class, which I have called Irregular, includes the Ode, poems in which the length of line follows no one of the preceding classes exclusively, Metrical Tales, and Songs; a subdivision I have called Prose Lyrics, to include much of Walt Whitman's poetry; another division

will contain those eccentricities, once popular, where poems are written in the shape of diamonds, crosses, pyramids, and so on. A subclass will contain Exotics, such as the Rondeau, Rondel, Ballade, Villanelle, &c.
The following table shows the classification in a concise manner, the name of a specimen poem being quoted with each by way of illustration:—
Class I.—Ballad.
A. Native.
| 1. |
Eight-stressed lines (16-syllabled) = Romance Metre (Parent Ballad)—
|
||||
| 2. |
Seven-stressed lines (14-syllabled) = Popular English Ballad—
|
||||
| 3. |
Seven-stressed lines (13-syllabled) = German Ballad: Nibelungen—
|
||||
| 4. |
Six-stressed lines (12-syllabled) = French Ballad: Alexandrine—
|
B. Exotic.
1. Six-stressed lines (syllables indefinite) = Greek Ballad: Imitation of Hexameter. (Longfellow's “Evangeline.”)
Class II.—Heroic.(All lines of five stresses.)
| 1. |
Heroic Couplet—
|
||||
| 2. |
Blank Verse—
|
Class III.—Irregular.
A. Native.
1. The Ode—
(a.) Ode, Song, Metrical Tale. (Dryden's “Alexander's Feast,” C. Rossetti's “Echo,” Southey's “Curse of Kehama.”)
(b.) Prose Lyrics. (Whitman's “President Lincoln's Burial Hymn.”)
2. Artificials—
Poems in shape of diamonds, crosses, &c. (Herrick's “Cross,” Withers's “Diamonds.”)
B. Exotic.
Rondeau, Rondel, Triolet, Ballade, Villanelle, Virelai, Pantoum, &c.

Lest these subdivisions appear at first sight very limited, the further subdivisions of Division 1 of the Ballad may be shown:—
Division 1 of Class I, Ballad.
(a.) Continuous.
(1.) Long Verse. (Tennyson's “Locksley Hall.”)
(2.) Split—
(a.) Ordinary (iambic). (Butler's “Hudibras.”)
(b.) Abrupt (trochaic). (Shelley's “Lines written among the Euganean Hills.”)
(3.) Trisyllabic. (Goldsmith's “The Retaliation.”)
(b.) Stanzaic.
| I. A. 1. (a.) | / | / | / | / | / | / | / | / | (1) |
| (b.) | / | / | / | / | / | / | / | / | (2) |
| (c.) | / | / | / | / | / | / | / | / | (3) |
| (d.) | / | / | / | / | / | / | / | / | (4) |
| (e.) | / | / | / | / | / | / | / | / | (5) |
| 2. (a.) | / | / | / | / | / | / | / | / | (6) |
| (b.) | / | / | / | / | / | / | / | / | (7) |
| (c.) | / | / | / | / | / | / | / | / | (8) |
| 3. (a.) | / | / | / | / | / | / | / | / | (9) |
| (b.) | / | / | / | / | / | / | / | / | (10) |
| (c.) | / | / | / | / | / | / | / | / | (11) |
| B. 1. (a.) | / | / | / | / | / | / | / | / | (12) |
| (b.) | / | / | / | / | / | / | / | / | (13) |
| (c.) | / | / | / | / | / | / | / | / | .(14) |
| (d.) | / | / | / | / | / | / | / | / | .(15) |
| 2. (e.) | / | / | / | / | / | / | / | / | .(16) |
| (a.) | / | / | / | / | / | / | / | / | .(17) |
| (b.) | / | / | / | / | / | / | / | / | .(18) |
| (c.) | / | / | / | / | / | / | / | / | .(19) |
| 3. (a.) | / | / | / | / | / | / | / | / | .(20) |
| (b.) | / | / | / | / | / | / | / | / | .(21) |
| (c.) | / | / | / | / | / | / | / | / | .(22) |
| C. 1. (a.) | / | / | / | / | / | / | / | / | .(23) |
| II. A. 1. (a.) | / | / | / | / | / | / | / | / | ..(24) |
| (b.) | / | / | / | / | / | / | / | / | ..(25) |
| (c.) | // | / | / | / | / | / | / | / | (26) |
| 2. (a.) | / | / | / | / | / | / | / | / | .(27) |
| (b.) | / | / | / | / | / | / | / | / | .(28) |
| 3. (a.) | / | / | / | / | / | / | / | / | ..(29) |
| (b.) | / | / | / | / | / | / | / | / | .(30) |
| B. 1. (a.) | / | / | / | / | / | / | / | / | ..(31) |
| (b.) | / | / | / | / | / | / | / | / | ..(32) |
| (c.) | / | / | / | / | / | / | / | / | ..(33) |
| 2. (a.) | / | / | / | / | / | / | / | / | …(34) |
| (b.) | / | / | / | / | / | / | / | / | .(35) |
| 3. (a.) | / | / | / | / | / | / | / | / | .(36) |
| (b.) | / | / | / | / | / | / | / | / | .(37) |
| C. 1. (a.) | / | / | / | / | / | / | / | / | ..(38) |

In the above table the units, of which there are eight in the Romance Metre, are divided off by the /, the syllable preceding the bar bearing the stress in every case: each represents a syllable.
Example (1) is then ordinary duple, or iambic metre; (2) is ordinary triple, or anapestic metre, with iambic opening; (3) is ordinary quadruple with iambic opening; (4) is pure triple; (5) is quadruple with triple opening; (6) is ordinary duple, the second half-line beginning abruptly, or with a stressed syllable; (9) is ordinary duple with a feminine first half-line, producing a triple unit in the middle of the verse.
Class B, (12) to (22), is exactly the same as Class A, (1) to (11), except that all the varieties in the former have feminine verse-ends.
Class C (23) may be extended in a similar way of Classes A and B; it differs from them in the verse ending with a double feminine, but this is of such rare occurrence that, unless specimens are actually found or made, it is unnecessary to cite the various varieties, all of which are, however, possible, and occur often enough in isolated couplets in eccentrics such as the “Ingoldsby Legends.”
Group II, again, is similar to Group I, except that throughout the former the beginning of the verse is abrupt—that is, it begins with a stressed syllable; so that, whilst Group I contains the so-called iambic and anapestic metres, Group II contains the trochaic and dactylic.
Those above tabled are the main variations. There are intermediate forms: for example, between (1) and (2) the following form often occurs:—
../…/…/…/…/…/…/…/…/..
where both half-lines of the triple metre begin with a duple unit. The extremes of variation only are given in the table, intermediate forms readily falling into their places.
It must be noted, however, that it is as much the exception as the rule to find verses entirely in any one of the above varieties. They may change from one to another, or hover around several of the forms in each of the Divisions A, B, and C, but they can always be readily assigned their place in the scheme. For instance, Shelley's “Sensitive Plant” is a mixture of duple and triple metre:—
A Sensitive Plant in a garden grew,
And the young winds fed it with silver dew,
And it opened its fan-like leaves to the light,
And closed them beneath the kisses of night.
This, divided into units, reads,—
A Sen/sitive Plant/ in a gar/den grew/, and the young/
winds fed/ it with sil/ver dew/,
And it o/pened its fan-/like leaves/ to the light/, and
closed/ them beneath/ the kis/ses of night./
or
../…/…/…/…/…/…/…/…/..
../…/…/…/…/…/…/…/…/..
It will be seen that it hovers between (a) and (d)—(1) and (4)—of Group I, Class A, Division 1.
The various divisions of the table have been made, as there is a vast number of poems that can be wholly placed in one or other of them. In the quotations following, the numbers correspond with the numbers of the variations in the table:—
| (1.) |
Ye banks/ and braes/ o' bon/me Doon/, how can/ ye bloom/ sae fresh/ and fair? |

| (2.) |
Our bu/gles sang truce/ for the night-/cloud had lower'd/, and the sen/tinel stars/ set their watch/ in the sky/. |
| (3.) |
An' half/ our bullicks per/ished when the drought/ was on the land/, an' the burn/in' heat that daz/zles as it dan/ces on the sand/. |
| (4.) |
The Assy/rian came down/like a wolf/on the fold/, and his co/-horts were gleam/ing in pur/ple and gold/. |
| (5.) |
And the bush/ hath friends to meet/him and their kind/ly voices greet/ him in the mur/mur of the breez/es and the riv/er on its bars/. |
| (6.) |
Since when/ all songs/ for jo/vial souls/ hav/ing no/thing, thought/divine/. |
| (7.) |
As gay/ as a lark/, and as blythe/ as a bee/, hand/some, gen/erous, spright/ly, and young/. |
| (8.) |
I have read/her roman/ces of dame/and knight/; she/was my prin/cess, my pride/, my pet/. |
| (9.) |
When love/ly wo/man stoops/ to fol/ly, and finds/ too late/ that men/ betray/. |
| (10.) |
Then up/ with the Ban/ner, let fo/rest winds fan/ her, she has blazed/ over Et/trick eight a/ges and more/. |
| (11.) |
Of the mail/ cover'd ba/rons, who proud/ly to bat/tle led their vas/sals from Eu/rope to Pal/estine's plain/. |
| (12.) |
And is/ she dead?/ and did/ they dare/ obey/my fren/zy's jea/lous ra/ving? |
| (13.) |
The pine/ boughs are sing/ing old songs/ with new glad/ness, the bil/lows and foun/tains fresh mu/sio are fling/ing. |
| (15.) |
At the dance/in the vil/lage thy white/foot was fleet/est; thy voice/ 'mid the con/cert of maid/ens was sweet/est. |
| (16.) |
And the dangh/ters of the Var/dens—they are beau/tiful as Gra/ces—but the bal/cony's deser/ted, and they rare/ly show their fa/ces. |
| (17.) |
Awake I/ my love/, the sun's/ bright ray/, hill/ and val/ley's now/adorn/ing. |
| (20.) |
Her voice/ did qui/ver as/ we part/ed, yet knew/ I not/ that heart/was brok/en. |
| (21.) |
The soul/ speaking eyes/ are the lan/guage of bliss/es, and we'll talk/ with our eyes/ amidst si/lent kiss/es. |
| (22.) |
Though thy beau/ty must fade/, yet thy youth/ I'll remem/ber: that thy May/ was my own/ when thou show/est Decem/ber. |
| (23.) | The coach/man then held/ the door fast/ in his hand/, to let/ me get out/ he was not/ at all will/ing, sirs.
|
| (24.) |
Aske/ me why/ I send/ you here/ this sweet/ Infan/ta of/ the veere?/ |
| (25.) |
Biid/ of the wil/derness, blith/some and cum/berless, light/ be thy ma/tin o'er wood/land and lea l/ |
| (27.) |
Must/thou go/my glo/rious chief/, se/ver'd from/thy faith/-ful few?/ |
| (28.) |
Hie/ upon Hie/ lands and low/ upon Tay/, bon/nie George Camp/bell rode out/ on a day/. |
| (29.) |
God/ be with/ thee, glad/some o/cean! how glad/ly greet/ I thee/ once more!/ |
| (31.) |
There's/ a wo/man like/ a dew-/drop, she's/ so pur/er than/ the pur/est. |

| (32.) |
Fair/ stood the wind/ for France, when/ we our sails/ advance, nor/ now to prove/ our chance long/er we tar/ry. |
| (34.) |
My/ dear Mis/tress has/ a heart/, soft/ as those/ kind looks/ she gave/ me. |
| (35.) |
Howl/ not, ye winds/, o'er the tomb/ of the brave/; roar/ not, ye waves/, at the foot/ of the moun/tain. |
| (36.) |
I/ will an/swer, These/ discov/er what faint/ing hopes/ are in/ a lov/er. |
There are several intermediate forms, of which entire poems are composed, and it might be found advisable to make divisions for their insertion. For example, the following form the scheme of well-known poems:—
Between (1) and (2),—
O, young/ Lochinvar/ is come out/ of the West/: through all/ the wide Bor/der his steed/ was the best/;
Between (12) and (13),—
Oh, say/ not, sweet Anne/, that the Fates/ have decreed/ the heart/ which adores/you should wish/ to dissev/er;
Between (24) and (25),—
Bright/est and best/ of the sons/ of the morn/ing I dawn/ on our dark/ness and lend/ us thine aid/;
Between (31) and (32),—
Where/ shall the lov/er rest, whom/ the fates sev/er from/ his true maid/en's breast/, parted for ev/er?
There are further irregular variations, as when Romance Metre mixes with Ballad or Alexandrine, Ballad with Alexandrine or Nibelungen, &c. The table shows only regular forms; the irregular, whilst they could be classified, are hardly of sufficient importance to warrant more than one general subdivision. Poems in regular structure vastly predominate, and it is, indeed, only because this is so that it has been found possible to compile the table.
Each of the other Ballad forms—Ordinary, Nibelungen, and Alexandrine—vary in the same way, though not to the same extent, as the Romance Metre.
The stanza form has not been taken as a standard of classification, as it varies in a manner altogether arbitrary: the line formations follow a definite law, and their variations from this law can readily be perceived. The stanza, on the other hand, appears to follow no fixed law, though it is a curious fact that the normal stanza of all the Ballad metres is composed of eight half-lines, and the parent Ballad line of eight stresses. The formation of the line is primarily rhythmical, then syntactical; the formation of the stanza appears to be primarily syntactical.
A few normal stanzas are quoted, to show the variation of form that may take place within the same metrical scheme:—
Variation (1).
Ye banks and braes o' bonnie Doon,
How can ye'bloom sae fresh and fair?
How can ye chant, ye little birds,
An' I sae weary, fu' o' care?
Thou'It break my heart, thou warbling bird,
That wantons thro' the flowering thorn:
Thou minds me o' departed joys,
Departed,—never to return.
(Burns,“The Banks o'Doon.”)

She's mounted on her milk-white steed,
And she's ta'en Thomas up behind;
And aye, whene'er her bridle rang,
The steed gaed swifter than the wind.
O they rade on, and farther on,
The steed gaed swifter than the wind;
Until they reached a desert wide,
And living land was left behind.
(“Thomas the Rhymer.”)
From Oberon, in fairye land,
The king of ghosts and shadows there,
Mad Robin I, at his command,
Am sent to viewe the night-sports here,
What revel rout
Is kept about,
In every corner where I go,
I will o'ersee,
And merry bee,
And make good sport, with ho, ho, ho!
(“Robin Good-Fellow.”)
With deep affection,
And recollection,
[xsoften think of
Those Shandon bells,
Whose sounds so wild would.
In the days of childhood,
Fling round my cradle
Their magic spells.
On this I ponder
Whene'er I wander,
And thus grow fonder,
Sweet Cork, of thee;
With thy bells of Shandon.
That sound so grand on
The pleasant waters
Of the river Lee.
(F. Mahony, “The Shandon Bells.”)
Variation (2).
Our bugles sang truce, for the night-cloud had lower'd,
And the sentinel stars set their watch in the sky;
And thousands had sunk to the ground, overpower'd,
The weary to sleep and the wounded to die.
When reposing that night on my pallet of straw,
By the wolf-scaring fagot, that guarded the slain,
In the dead of the night a sweet vision I saw,
And thrice ere the morning I dreamt it again.
(Campbell, “The Soldier's Dream.”)
(Half-stanzas.)
The glad birds are singing,
The gay flowrets springing,
O'er meadow and mountain and down in the vale;
The green leaves are bursting;
My spirit is thirsting
To bask in the sunbeams, and breathe the fresh gale.
(Barton, “Spring.”)
By love and by beauty,
By law and by duty,
I swear to be true to
My Eppie Adair!

A' pleasure exile me,
Dishonour defile me,
If e'er I beguile thee,
My Eppie Adair!
(Burns, “Eppie Adair.”)
Variation (4).
(Half-stanzas.)
The Assyrian came down like a wolf on the fold,
And his cohorts were gleaming in purple and gold,
And the sheen of their spears was like stars on the sea,
When the blue wave rolls nightly on deep Galilee.
(Byron, “The Destruction of Sennacherib.”)
'Tis the last rose of summer
Left blooming alone;
All her lovely companions
Are faded and gone;
No flower of her kindred
No rosebud, is nigh,
To reflect back her blushes
Or give sigh for sigh.
(Moore, “The Last Rose of Summer.”)
It will be seen that the same rhythm runs through all these examples, the variations being external—as it were in the matter of scent and colour.
Besides showing poets and others what forms had been much or little used, a classification of English poetry on these lines might lead to the discovery of yet more laws guiding its growth.
