
An Ecological Study of the Vegetation of the Cromwell District, with Special Reference to Root Habit.
[Issued separately, 31st March, 1932.]
Contents.
- Introduction.
- Previous Work.
- Experimental Procedure.
- The Root Habit of Various Species:
- Pao caesiptosa.
- Raoulia lutescens.
- Carmichaelia Petriei.
- Carmichaelia subulata.
- Hymenanthera dentata var. alpina.
- Lepidium sisymbrioides.
- Geranium sessiliflorum.
- Chenopodium glaucum.
- Erodium cicutarium.
- The Factors of the Habitai.
-
I.—Climatic Factors:
-
Light.
-
Rainfall.
-
Humidity.
-
Temperature.
-
Wind.
- II.—Physiographic Factors.
- III.—Edaphic Factors.
- IV.—Biotic Factors.
- Observations Upon the Vegetation.
- The Leaf Anatomy of Some of the Plants.
- Conclusions and Discussion.
- Summary.
- Literature Citations.
*Introduction.
That the subterranean parts of plants possess a configuration which is just as characteristic of the species as the more familiar subaerial portions, is increasingly being recognised. The labour involved in making proper observations upon roots has naturally discouraged their examination, but it will be apparent that the fuller knowledge of plants which is afforded by a study of their root habit should make for more thorough understanding of their ecological relations. Weaver (1919, p. 1) has pointed out that, “A knowledge of root distribution and root competition under different natural conditions, is not only of much scientific value, but it also finds practical application in a better understanding of the value of plants as indicators for distinguishing lands of grazing value only, from those with
[Footnote] * The author's thanks are due to the Rev. Dr John E. Holloway, not only for his original suggestion of the subject, but for his aid and criticism throughout.

possibilities of crop production. It will result in a more intelligent solution of the ecological problems of grazing, and will likewise be of great aid to the forester in selecting sites for afforestation. Moreover a knowledge of root distribution will throw a flood of light upon many problems of succession. Indeed, the phenomena of ecesis, competition, and reaction cannot be completely, if indeed correctly interpreted, without a knowledge of the extent, position, and relation of the root-systems of the plants.”
The area considered in this study is that part of the Upper Clutha Valley lying around Cromwell and Lowburn Ferry, Central Otago (Fig. 1). It was selected for study for the special reason that it is fairly representative of a much larger area of Central Otago. which experiences the driest climate of any region of New Zealand. Reference to Figure 2, which shows the average annual distribution of rainfall over the South Island, will give an indication of the approximate location and extent of this larger area. The area dealt with in the present study is situated in the neighbourhood of Cromwell, Clyde, and Alexandra, and has been referred to by various authors as the “depleted area.” At Clyde, the average annual precipitation is about 15 inches, while near Alexandra it is still lower. Originally, the land was covered by a close tussock vegetation, but owing to the influence of biotic factors introduced some sixty years ago, the district now presents an aspect of semi-aridity.
The main purpose of this investigation was to make a study of the root-systems of some of the more common plants of the district, with a view to relating the information so gained with the problems of succession and distribution.
Previous Work.
The only noteworthy ecological observations upon the locality under review are those contained in a series of articles by L. Cockayne, in the New Zealand Journal of Agriculture, under the title of “An Economic Investigation of the Montane Tussock Grassland of New Zealand.” As the title suggests, the paper was written from an economic rather than an ecological standpoint, and a description of the vegetation of the north face of the Dunstan Range forms but a part of it. For the purpose of the present study, this paper, however, has been very useful. The same author gives a short account of the “transformation of steppe into induced-desert,” in Die Vegetation der Erde, vol. 14, p. 289. Valuable information with regard to the habit and anatomy of the above-ground parts of some of the plants dealt with has also been obtained from papers by Foweraker (1917), and also by Miss Betts (1919).
In New Zealand, no recorded systematic work has previously been carried out upon the root habit of indigenous plants. It must be emphasised, however, that such information as has been gained by the present study is but a small beginning. Before generalisations can be made, a larger number of individuals of each species should be examined in different stations, as well as a greater variety of

species. The nature of the work entailed is distinctly arduous, and the difficulties of working single-handed at such a task will be appreciated.
Experimental Procedure.
Method of Examination of Roots:
The method adopted was largely that described by Weaver (1919, p. 2). A trench was dug alongside the selected plant, about 2 to 3 feet wide, 9 to 15 feet long, and to a depth of about 6 feet. Thus an open face was exposed, from which the root-system could be dissected with a small trowel and a spike made from a piece of stout fencing wire. Thus the roots present in a vertical section about 4 to 6 inches wide, 9 to 15 feet long, and 6 feet deep could be examined. This is taken as representative of the whole system (Fig. 3).
As Weaver states, extreme care must be observed in excavating root termini, to ascertain their maximum depth. To ensure this, the soil was undercut some inches below the deepest roots and carefully examined as it was removed.
Various practical difficulties had to be surmounted. In the first place, to avoid confusion with the roots of neighbouring plants of the same species, or even of other species, the specimen examined was selected generally in a more or less isolated position. Anyone who has seen the close manner in which plants of Raoulia lutescens grow in suitable stations, will appreciate the difficulty involved in excafcating a root-system of a single plant distinct from others in such a station.
As the work had to be done as expeditiously as possible, it important that plants growing in easily workable soils should be selected. Obviously it would be a hopeless task to excavate the rootsystem of Raoulia lutescens growing on the very rocky Dunstan Mountains. Accordingly, specimens selected were for the most part growing upon the gravel terraces which characterise the valley of the Upper Clutha River. These terraces attain a great thickness and vary in the size of the stones composing the gravel of which they are composed. The gravel in some terraces is very unstable, and the formation of gulches is of common occurrence.
Considerable difficulty was experienced from caving of the loose sandy gravel. In some cases, excavation beyond a certain depth had to be abandoned on this account.
Weaver (1919) has shown that different soil habitats modify the root systems of many plants. Thus it must be borne in mind that the characters of the roots illustrated are not necessarily of general occurrence, although it is fairly certain that where the soil offers no serious obstruction to the roots in the form of rocks, hard-pans, etc., the general configuration of the various systems will be similar to those described.

General:
As the district is situated some 142 miles by road from Dunedin, only periodic visits could be made to it. The observations extended over a period of seven months, from the end of February to the beginning of September, 1928, too short a time in which to make a complete investigation. During this period four visits were made to the locality. These were on the following dates:
- February 24 to March 1.
- April 16 to April 20.
- May 26 to June 6.
- August 25 to September 1.
The order followed in this paper will be a description of the root habits of a number of plants, followed by an account of the environmental conditions under which they grow. These considerations will then be incorporated into a brief account of the communities and their distribution, together with some observations upon the above-ground parts of the plants.
The Root Habit of Various Species.
Poa caespitosa Forst.
The wide distribution of this grass together with Festuca Novae-Zelandiae Cockayne throughout New Zealand—a country of very diverse climates—indicates that these grasses can apparently thrive under a variety of environmental conditions. The characteristic “tussock” growth form is a feature which it possesses in common with a number of other indigenous grasses. (Cockayne, 1921, p. 107 and p. 167).
The larger specimen figured,* (Fig. 6) was excavated on May 27. It was growing on slightly inclined ground, subjected to the slow accumulation of wind-blown sand. Consequently the upper 9 inches of soil was almost pure sand, and this overlaid a considerable depth of sandy gravel containing many water-worn stones of various sizes, up to the size of an egg. In this and other specimens excavated, the grass is characteristically shallow-rooted, rarely penetrating beyond three feet. The lateral extension, however, is fairly wide, the roots in some cases reaching out to a distance of about three feet from the basal culm. The main roots are about 1 mm. in diameter at their origin, pale brown in colour, and remain more or less uniform in diameter throughout their length, ending more or less abruptly. The character of the soil modifies considerably the character of the roots. In this plant, in the upper 9 inches, where the soil was almost pure sand, the main roots pursued a more or less straight course without much bending or kinking. The laterals borne upon this region were short (¾-inch long) and numerous, arising from the main root almost at right angles to it. These laterals carried smaller rootlets which,
[Footnote] * In all drawings of root systems, the squared lines represent distances of one foot.

however, were very rudimentary. In the lower region, as soon as the roots entered the stony gravel, they became more bent, probably consequent upon the necessity for bending around the stones. The laterals of the first order were here longer than those in the upper 9 inches of soil, reaching a length of 3 to 4 inches, and they carried laterals of the second order which were better developed than those of the upper region.
The soil immediately below the surface was filled with a compact mass of fibrous roots.
Figure 7 illustrates the root system of a plant growing upon the Cromwell Flat adjoining Cromwell township. The upper 9 inches of the ground was composed of a light-coloured soil, which passed abruptly into a fine gravel. The lateral extension of the roots is here well evidenced, many of the roots pursuing an almost horizontal course for about two feet before turning gradually downwards. A striking feature here was the presence of a number of new roots induced by fairly heavy rain after a sustained drought. These roots were about 2 mm. in diameter, and possessed a thick, white slimy cortex, which rubbed off easily. Laterals were quite absent from them, but presumably these would appear when the roots became older. This plant was excavated on May 28.
Figure 8 shows the development of the roots of a specimen growing on the face of a terrace. The habitat was one of extreme mobility. The angle of slope was about 30°, and consequently the crown of the plant was continually subjected to a constant pressure exerted by the upper layer of gravel, slowly sliding down the slope. The response of the plant in the development of anchoring roots to withstand this pressure is striking. All the roots carried a profuse covering of laterals about ¾-inch long, the whole system being well adapted to absorption from the surface soil. (To avoid complexity, the laterals have been omitted from the figure). The depth of penetration at right angles to the surface was not more than two feet. The development of a surface root-system and also anchoring roots are characters found by Weaver (1919) in his investigation of the gravel slides of the Rocky Mountains.
Cockayne (1921, p. 167) asserts that “when on dry ground, (the tussock's) long, deeply-descending roots reach the ground water, while its numerous short ones passing into the water-absorbing dead leaves at its base can take advantage of even brief showers.” That absorption may take place from the dead leaves is not doubted, but the statement that the tussock produces deep roots which absorb moisture from the ground-water seems incorrect. Four specimens were examined, and in no case did the roots descend lower than 3 feet 6 inches, nor were they observed to reach the ground-water.
Raoulia lutescens Beauv.
On the depleted slopes of the Dunstan Range, this plant is the most conspicuous feature of the landscape, and at first sight appears to be in almost sole possession. Foweraker (1916) describes its growth-form as a true “cushion” (Fig. 5). Owing to the very

rocky nature of the soil, it was found extremely difficult to excavate a root system satisfactorily on the Range, and accordingly two plants growing on the lower terraces were examined. The plants in each case were about 2 feet in diameter.
The extent of the root-system is surprising, considering the relatively small amount of leaf surface which the plant exposes, and the intensely xerophytic nature of the above-ground parts. The soil in which the specimens examined were growing was a light gravel containing much sand of a very absorbent nature. The soil directly underneath the plant was packed with slender adventitious roots. These roots are brown in colour, about 1 mm. in diameter near the surface, and very brittle. They taper imperceptibly towards their termini, ending in a well-developed branch system, the branches being produced to the second and third order. The lateral extension is not great, but the depth to which the roots penetrate—about 6 feet—is no doubt a very important factor in the water economy of the plant. It is evident from Figure 9 that the root development is extensive, exposing a large absorptive surface. This character of the root-system, combined with the reduced and protected leaf surface, has no doubt been the chief means in determining the dominance of Raoulia lutescens throughout the “arid” areas of Central Otago. At the time the examination was made (April 18), a comparatively heavy three days' rain had fallen, following on a five months' virtual drought. The sustained drought had caused almost all plants except the Raoulias to become desiccated. The latter still retained their usual glaucous green appearance.
In the second specimen examined, two months later (June 4), some of the roots in the upper soil carried small bunches of rudimentary roots (Fig. 10). These peculiar rootlets may have been developed for absorption of the surface moisture which had accumulated at this time. Repeated examination at subsequent intervals would prove whether or not these rudimentary roots are deciduous.
The complete possession of the soil by the roots of this species, must, and does set up considerable competition with the roots of individuals of the same species and also of other species. Where the plants are more or less scattered, as on the terraces, this effect can be seen in the more stunted growth of the smaller annuals and perennials in a concentric ring immediately around the plant. (Fig. 4).
Carmichaelia Petriei T. Kirk.
The leafless nature of this leguminous plant at once indicates it as a special xerophyte. The cylindrical cladodes are sparingly branched, and the plant generally attains a height of about 4 feet. It is not very common in the district under review, but owing to its remarkable root-system and obvious xerophytic structure, a number of specimens were excavated. An idea of the appearance of the plant can be obtained by reference to Figure 3.
The root development of a specimen about 3 feet in height is shown in Figure 11. The soil consisted of light sand to a depth of 4 feet. The upper three feet was damp at the time of examination

(April 19), due to recent rains, and this was succeeded by a foot of perfectly dry sand. At the 4-feet level there was a stratum of fine damp gravel, which fell away easily, presenting no difficulty for penetration by roots.
The plant possessed a main taproot about 1½ inches diameter at the top. The branches of the plant joined the root below the ground level, forming a multicipital crown. At a depth of 18 inches, the taproot divided into two equal branches, one of which could not be followed. The other continued downwards to a depth of 4 feet, where it turned abruptly in a horizontal direction. From the taproot in its uppermost 18 inches arose six main laterals which all pursued an almost horizontal course for about two feet, when they turned downwards abruptly, taking a vertically downward direction to a depth of 4 feet, when all took a horizontal course. This sudden deviation of the roots at the 4-feet level is striking, and is coincident with the stratum of damp sand which occurred at this level. This damp layer was doubtless the capillary fringe of the water-table. (The capillary fringe is defined as that stratum of soil immediately above the level of the standing water-table, into which the water rises by capillary attraction). At a distance of about a hundred yards from the position of the plant was situated a small artesian well, which by its constant flow may have maintained the water-table at a fairly constant height. The coincidence of the horizontal extension of the roots with the damp layer might be interpreted as a response on the part of the roots to the special conditions obtaining. Possibly a response to the stimulus of water was in evidence, or lack of aeration at greater depth may have determined the condition.
All the upper portions of the main roots showed little branching. The main mass of absorbing roots was at the 4-feet level, where profuse bunches of roots branched to the third order were situated. A number of small roots were, however, produced from the taproot in its upper portion. The roots are rich brown in colour, quite tough and flexible. The horizontal root at the left of Figure 11 was followed for a further distance of 3 feet before it was finally lost.
In Figure 12 is shown the root-system of another specimen growing in a similar type of soil. A glance at the figure will show that the lateral extension of the roots is far greater than in the first specimen, for here they were found to extend horizontally to a distance of 9 feet. A ground plan of this development is seen in Figure-13. A taproot is again present, but here it turned sharply to the left at the 2-feet level, a smaller branch of the main root continuing vertically downwards to a maximum depth of 5 feet 6 inches, after having divided into a number of smaller branches. Although the lateral root to the right of the figure showed considerable horizontal extension, it eventually turned abruptly downwards at a distance of 9 feet from the base of the plant. The horizontal extension of the taproot to the left was lost at a distance of 9 feet from the crown of the plant. There was found to be no definite damp stratum in this case, the soil becoming imperceptibly damper from a depth of 4 feet 6 inches downwards. Possibly in this spot the level of the

capillary fringe was subject to fluctuation, which would account for the absence of a constant depth of turning to a horizontal course as exhibited by the roots of the previous example.
Figure 14 illustrates the root-system of a plant which grew on the edge of a steep terrace. The habitat was one of extreme exposure, and the level of the ground to one side of the plant sloped sharply downwards at a steep angle. It could reasonably be assumed that in such a position the water-table would be far below the surface, and that the roots would necessarily depend upon water percolating from the surface. The plant showed the same development of a taproot, and a system of laterals which after traversing a variable horizontal distance, eventually turned sharply downwards. This feature would seem therefore to be a constant one, modified to a different extent in different localities. In accordance with the absence of a definite damp layer, there was found to be no definite depth of absorption. The soil was actually of a similar degree of dampness at all depths (there had been recent rains), and apparently absorption took place at any depth. The development and distribution of the finer absorbing bunches of rootlets, as shown in the figure, was in accordance with this conclusion.
On both the last two specimens, a number of adventitious roots were developed from the multicipital crown of the plant.
The very characteristic configuration of the root-system of this species is seen also in C. subulata T. Kirk, a species very similar in growth form to C. Petriei, but having more slender cladodes. A specimen was found growing on the edge of a disused sluicing pit, and by removing some of the face of the cliff, the roots were exposed. The same development of taproot and horizontal laterals which eventually turned abruptly downwards was again present. In this case, however, the depth of penetration was much greater, for at a depth of 10 feet, the roots were still 3 mm. in diameter. In such a position, the water-table would naturally be very low.
The horizontal extension of the lateral roots at a depth of six inches to two feet was thus characteristic of all four specimens of Carmichaelia which were examined, and as such deserves special notice. The region in which these plants grow is characterised by short, irregular rain-showers, which either run off quickly or are soon absorbed by the porous soil. It is probable that the presence of this shallow root system enables the plants to use to best advantage the irregular supply of water, while the deeper roots make use of moisture at deeper levels.
Carmichaelia Petriei is a leguminous plant, but it is peculiar that bacterial nodules were found to be extremely rare, and were of an unusual form, being larger and more branched than those found on common legumes such as peas or beans.
Hymenanthera dentata var. alpina T. Kirk.
This plant is by no means necessarily confined to sub-alpine regions. In certain places on the terraces, it occurs as rounded, compact, wind-moulded clumps about 1 foot in height (Fig. 22).

It is sparsely provided with leaves, and those which it has are quite small.
Only one specimen was excavated, on June 1. It was rather a small one, about 1 foot across and about 6 inches in height. It is typical of all the plants of this species in this locality that the crown occupies a bowl-shaped depression in the ground.
The root-system was characterised by a main taproot which measured 15 cms. in diameter at its origin and descended vertically—except for undulations and compressions—to a depth of 5 feet 6 inches, where it divided into two almost equal branches, which both pursued a horizontal course (Fig. 15). These were each followed for a distance of 4 feet, tapering extremely slowly, and were still 2 mm. in diameter when further excavation was abandoned. Judging from the degree of tapering which they showed, they must certainly have continued for at least another four feet.
The taproot gave rise to a number of horizontal laterals which attained a maximum lateral extension of 3 feet 6 inches, and ended in well developed rootlets, branched to the third and fourth order. The laterals in the uppermost foot showed a tendency to turn upwards and to approach closer to the surface. The soil for a depth of 10 inches from the surface was fine and brown, and was quite damp from recent rains. The surface root development was probably correlated with the presence of surface moisture at intermittent periods.
Comparatively few fine rootlets were borne upon the taproot itself, these being much more common on the horizontal laterals. The roots are light yellow in colour, and rather tough in texture.
As far as could be ascertained by actual visual and tactile examination, the distribution of soil moisture on the day of examination was as follows:—
| Upper 10 inches | damp brown soil. |
| Next 4 inches | fine damp gravel. |
| Next 2ft 10in | fine dry gravel. |
| Below this | fine damp gravel. |
Thus the surface moisture due to winter rains extended to a depth of 1ft 2in, followed by a dry stratum to a depth of 4 feet. At this depth the gravel again became damp, presumably on acount of the capillary rise from the actual water-table.
The plant thus exhibits a well defined surface absorbing system, as well as a deeper absorbing system collecting from the capillary fringe. No doubt the existence of laterals at intermediate levels indicates that winter rains may at times penetrate to these depths. It is probable also that the roots can absorb moisture from soil which to outward appearance seems dry.
Liepidium sisymbrioides Hook.
This cruciferous plant is not at all common in the Cromwell district. In fact, its occurrence is rather sporadic, and specimens had to be searched for carefully. The above-ground part of the plant is very small, the average diameter being about 5 inches, and the radical leaves lie horizontally, close to the ground.

The root-system, however, is totally out of proportion to the size of the above-ground part. Two specimens were examined, on June 4 and 5. A prominent taproot is the main feature, about 8 mm. in diameter at its origin just below the multicipital crown, and in the two plants excavated, it penetrated to a depth of over 6 feet. (Fig. 16). The taproot was extensively bent and kinked in avoiding large stones on its way downwards. In the specimen figured, it tapered very gradually and at a depth of 6 feet 2 inches, when further excavation was rendered dangerous by caving shingle, it was still .5 mm. in diameter. There were no laterals of any size, those that were given off being very thin and sparsely branched to the second order. The taproot was light yellowish brown in colour, and rather brittle.
To a depth of 5 feet the shingle was dry. At this depth, however, it became damp to the touch. The cortex of the root is thick in proportion to the stele, and it is probable that the plant's method of tiding over drought periods is to draw upon the moisture stored in the wide cortex.
Geranium sessiliflorum Cav.
This species is a very common member of the turf community, especially on the gravel terraces. The leaves lie close to the ground, their petioles springing directly from the multicipital crown of the taproot. One specimen was excavated entirely, but five others were examined to a depth of one foot. The taproot of the plant excavated entirely (Fig. 17) was about 15 mm. in diameter at its origin, and after descending vertically for a distance of 10 inches it divided into two almost equal branches, one of which continued downwards without major branches to a depth of 5 feet. The other branch divided at the 2-feet level, and the two branches so formed also continued downwards to a depth of 5 feet. From the taproot in its upper foot, a number of almost horizontal laterals were produced which branched in the upper soil to the second order. This production of surface laterals was found to be a constant feature in the five other plants examined. From the main divisions of the taproot comparatively few small laterals were produced, their number increasing, however, as the fifth foot was reached.
The taproot has a papery bark which is almost black, and which readily peels off, showing the reddish, woody, central tissues.
Chenopodium glaucum Linn.
Parts of the river banks, especially along the base of the Dunstan Range, are characterised by the presence of a salty efflorescence, which appears as white patches upon the surface. These patches are almost invariably colonised by Chenopodium glaucum, often in company with Atriplex Buchanani. C. glaucum is a summer annual, with fleshy, succulent, and prostrate leaves. The three root-systems shown in Figure 18 are those of three plants excavated on April 17. They are drawn to one-half natural size. It will be seen that a taproot is the dominant feature, which divides sooner or later into major branches.

The minor branches are thin and poorly developed. In two of the specimens figured, the taproot carries in its upper region small bunches of rudimentary rootlets, but in the third these are absent, being replaced by longer single rootlets. The taproot in all was about 4 mm. in diameter at its origin, did not penetrate more than 12 inches, and was white and soft in texture.
In comparison with the above-ground parts, which are thick, fleshy, and fairly widely spreading (up to 18 inches long), the root system is very poorly developed. The fine saline soil in which the plant habitually lives is retentive of moisture, and that which is absorbed by the roots is stored efficiently in the leaves.
Both Chenopodium glaucum and Atriplex Buchanani are halophytes occurring not uncommonly in sandy places near the sea, and the occurrence of a saline soil in the inland Cromwell district provides a suitable habitat for these plants.
Erodium cicutarium L'Herit.
This species, an introduced one, forms such an important constituent of the plant covering that it becomes dominant in the terrace community in the winter months. It is worthy of notice that Cannon (1911, p. 34) mentions it as becoming very widely spread in the deserts of Arizona. It is a true winter annual. Ten specimens were examined on June 1. The dominant feature of the root-system is a white fleshy taproot, which descends to an average depth of about 15 inches, tapering rapidly, and occasionally forking. The uppermost two inches of the taproot is generally provided with numerous short laterals, which arise in groups. Below this region are present a varying number of larger laterals (5 to 10) about 2 to 5 mm. in diameter at their origin, which may extend outwards and downwards for about a foot. These laterals carry smaller branches which are not extensively branched. (Fig. 19). Cannon (loc. cit. p. 24) mentions that a feature of the root-system of this plant is the poor development of laterals, but this character was not in evidence in the case of the plants examined in the present investigation.
The Factors of the Habitat.
I.—Climatic Factors:
Unfortunately, no meteorological station is situated at Cromwell, so that records of rainfall, temperature, wind, etc., are not available for the actual locality under consideration. But the area forms part of a more widely spread region which can be considered to have a very similar climate. A certain amount of data are available from Clyde and Earnscleugh, some 12 miles to the south-west of Cromwell, and from Ophir, in the valley of the Manuherikia River, a tributary of the Clutha. The general climatic conditions of these places are similar and can be taken as almost identical with those of Cromwell. The actual extent of the district which is considered in this paper is shown in Figures 1 and 20.

Light.—No exact instrumental data are available, but it is clear that the isolation to which the district is subjected is generally considerable. In summer, bright sunny days follow one another with regular monotony. The sky is generally free of clouds and the heat is often intense. During winter and spring, however, though sunny days are common, dense mists may hang over the valleys and tops of the ranges, completely obscuring the sun sometimes for days at a time. In the hot season, the light is made more intense on sandy bare areas by the reflection which occurs from them.
Rainfall.—The limiting factor of the environment is certainly the moisture available in the soil. The mean monthly and annual precipitation for Clyde is given in Table I, while similar data for Earnscleugh is given in Table II.
[The section below cannot be correctly rendered as it contains complex formatting. See the image of the page for a more accurate rendering.]
| Months. | Precipitation. | No. of Rain Days. |
|---|---|---|
| Jan. | 1.82 | 7.2 |
| Feb. | 1.04 | 5.0 |
| Mar. | 1.48 | 6.3 |
| April | 1.45 | 5.9 |
| May | 1.05 | 6.0 |
| June | .95 | 5.4 |
| July | .91 | 4.9 |
| Aug. | .82 | 5.8 |
| Sept. | 1.03 | 6.2 |
| Oct. | 1.62 | 7.9 |
| Nov. | 1.32 | 6.8 |
| Dec. | 1.80 | 7.7 |
| Annual | 15.29 | 75.1 |
Table I.—Mean monthly and annual precipitation and mean monthly and annual number of rain days at Clyde. (These figures supplied by Govt. Meteorologist).
[The section below cannot be correctly rendered as it contains complex formatting. See the image of the page for a more accurate rendering.]
| Months. | Precipitation. |
|---|---|
| Jan. | 1.74 |
| Feb. | 1.10 |
| Mar. | 1.47 |
| April | 1.62 |
| May | 1.36 |
| June | .89 |
| July | .85 |
| Aug. | 1.22 |
| Sept. | .83 |
| Oct. | 1.70 |
| Nov. | .99 |
| Dec. | 1.42 |
| Annual | 15.19 |
Table II.—Mean monthly and annual precipitation at Earnscleugh over a period of seven years (1920–1926).
It will be seen from these figures that the monthly precipitation is low, and apparently more or less evenly distributed over the whole year. But consideration of these figures alone would give an entirely misleading conception of the amount of moisture in the soil at different times of the year. Considering the Clyde data, it is precisely in those months which show the lowest rainfall, viz., May to September, that the soil is wettest. The reason for this is to be found in the wide difference between the amounts of evaporation in winter and summer. During winter and spring, i.e., from about May to the end of October, the soil is generally quite damp to a depth of several feet, and it seems remarkable to an observer at this period that the plant covering is so sparse on the soil which appears eminently suited to carry a much more abundant vegetation.

The penetrating power of the moisture is considerably lessened by other factors. On the steep Dunstan slopes, the surface is baked hard, and in places is free of soil altogether. Much of the rain which falls comes in short, sharp, and heavy downpours, which runs off extremely rapidly. The effect of these downpours is to convert dry watercourses into torrents which scour out the soil, exposing the underlying rock. After a storm, a few hours of the hot summer sun causes the ground to take on its previous parched appearance.
On the flat terraces, however, there is little or no run-off. But the underlying formation is a lightly compacted gravel into which moisture sinks very rapidly. One of the difficulties with which farmers must contend is the serious loss of water which takes place from the water-races dug in the porous ground.
Another characteristic of the rainfall is that the same months of different years often show considerable variation in the amount of precipitation. Table III gives the monthly rainfall at Earnscleugh for the period 1921–1927. A glance at the table will show that October, generally the wettest month of the year, was in 1922 easily the driest. Although January (generally the hottest month) has an average of 1.57 inches, yet in 1928 it had only .39 inches. Study of the data of Table III will show further variations of a similar nature.
[The section below cannot be correctly rendered as it contains complex formatting. See the image of the page for a more accurate rendering.]
| Month. | 1921 | 1922 | 1923 | 1924 | 1925 | 1926 | 1927 | 1928 | Monthly Averages. |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Jan. | .83 | 2.17 | 2.92 | 2.98 | .45 | 1.72 | 1.12 | .39 | 1.57 |
| Feb. | .65 | .67 | .76 | .85 | 1.09 | 2.76 | .93 | 1.48 | 1.15 |
| Mar. | 1.03 | 1.55 | 1.07 | .64 | 2.70 | .27 | 3.08 | 1.04 | 1.42 |
| April | .83 | 1.72 | 1.48 | 3.05 | .83 | 1.12 | 1.30 | 2.79 | 1.64 |
| May | .84 | .81 | 1.89 | .62 | .31 | 2.48 | .62 | .58 | 1.02 |
| June | 1.61 | .39 | 1.57 | 1.01 | .37 | .68 | .50 | .40 | .82 |
| July | 2.21 | .96 | .21 | .95 | .97 | .14 | .56 | 1.60 | .95 |
| Aug. | .53 | .78 | .57 | .18 | 2.33 | .82 | .34 | .79 | |
| Sept. | .96 | .52 | .11 | 1.11 | .78 | 1.06 | 1.28 | .83 | |
| Oct. | 2.08 | .15 | .82 | 2.68 | 2.51 | 2.47 | 1.23 | 1.71 | |
| Nov. | .42 | 1.62 | .58 | 1.13 | .99 | 1.30 | .90 | .99 | |
| Dec. | 1.76 | 2.05 | 1.48 | .95 | 1.52 | 1.74 | .46 | 1.42 | |
| Yearly Totals | 13.75 | 13.39 | 13.46 | 16.15 | 14.85 | 16.56 | 12.32 |
Table III.—Monthly and yearly rainfall (in inches) at Earnscleugh, 1921–1928.
The average number of days upon which rain falls during the year at Clyde is 75, a figure which gives an indication of the preponderance of dry days.
On the area considered in this study, only very occasional falls of snow are recorded. These are at most very light, and never lie on the ground more than a few days. On the ranges, however, which reach an altitude of more than 5000 feet, snow lies continuously above the 3000-foot level during the winter and spring months. This region is not considered here.
Humidity.—Information on this point is available from general observation only. Collection of exact observations would have required constant presence in the locality. It is apparent, however,

that the air humidity in summer is generally very low. The prevailing westerly winds have already deposited their moisture upon the mountains to the west, and by the time they blow over Central Otago they are warm and dry. During the winter and spring, however, owing to the prevalent mists, evaporation is slight and air humidity must frequently be high.
As a factor correlated with the study of root-systems, data bearing upon the soil water-content at different times and different depths would be important. This also requires constant presence upon the scene, and ideally, a laboratory on the spot. The only information that can be given on this point is that gained by visual examination while excavating the root-systems. As Weaver points out (1919, p. 24), root variations are probably due to a number of factors, among which water content of the soil and its penetrability probably stand first in importance.
Temperature.—New Zealand is commonly said to enjoy an insular climate, and for the most part this is the case. But in Central Otago, the widest region of the South Island, there is found an approach to continental range of temperature. The Cromwell district does not experience the lower temperatures of some other parts of Otago during the winter, but nevertheless the temperature occasionally reaches 15° Fahr. On the other hand, in summer, shade temperatures of over 100° Fahr. are not uncommon.
Table IV gives the mean monthly maximum and minimum temperatures at Earnscleugh over a period of four years, 1921 to 1924, inclusive. Additional data are not available for the extraction of a more accurate mean.
[The section below cannot be correctly rendered as it contains complex formatting. See the image of the page for a more accurate rendering.]
| Month. | Max. | Min. |
|---|---|---|
| Jan. | 97 | 37 |
| Feb. | 92 | 33 |
| Mar. | 89 | 31 |
| April | 75 | 26 |
| May | 64 | 22 |
| June | 55 | 21 |
| July | 52 | 20 |
| Aug. | 64 | 22 |
| Sept. | 77 | 25 |
| Oct. | 81 | 28 |
| Nov. | 90 | 31 |
| Dec. | 93 | 33 |
Table IV.—Mean monthly maximum and minimum temperatures in degrees Fahr. at Earnscleugh from 1921 to 1924.
It will be noted from these figures that even in the summer months (November to February) while the maximum temperature is high; the minimum temperatures recorded at night are often low, so that the vegetation is subjected to considerable diurnal and nocturnal extremes.
Going into the question more fully, and taking the year 1924 as an example, the records show that in January there occurred one day with a maximum temperature of 102° Fahr., while there were eighteen days over 80°. In February, there were twenty days over 80°, and in March, nine days over 80°. In the following November, there were fourteen days over 80°, and in December, eight days over 80°. These figures show that the high temperatures reached are the rule rather than the exception during the summer months.

Figures are available from Ophir giving the number of frosts recorded on the grass monthly. At this place a frost is regarded as any record below 30.4° Fahr. Table V gives these figures, and they are instructive in showing the duration and frequency of the low temperatures, especially during the winter months.
[The section below cannot be correctly rendered as it contains complex formatting. See the image of the page for a more accurate rendering.]
| Month: | Jan. | Feb. | Mar. | April. | May. | June. | July | Aug. | Sept. | Oct. | Nov. | Dec. |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1926 | 3 | 2 | 9 | 12 | 24 | 30 | 29 | 29 | 19 | 16 | 12 | 8 |
| 1927 | 8 | 8 | 11 | 19 | 29 | 30 | 27 | 30 | 21 | 14 | 9 | 5 |
Table V.—No. of frosts recorded on the grass monthly at Ophir.
It will be seen that during the winter months frosts occur regularly—on almost every night. Moreover, the maximum temperature on many days of the winter months does not rise above 32° Fahr., and consequently the ground is frequently frozen hard for weeks at a time.
Wind.—During the hot summer especially, the area is subjected to violent winds from the north-west. These occur not infrequently and with great velocity, and are usually warm and dry. In conjunction with the intense insolation and low humidity, their effect is desiccating in the extreme, and evaporation must reach a maximum. These strong winds have been instrumental in moulding the sandy flat which characterises that part of the valley adjacent to Cromwell township. The sand is believed by some to have been brought down by the Clutha in the great flood of 1878, but Park (1908, p. 35) suggests a more likely source. He states that “this would doubtless account for a large proportion of the sand, but the terrace on which Cromwell is built contains a large amount of drift-sand mixed with the gravels, and a constant supply of this sand, derived from the terrace faces between Lowburn and Deadman's Point, is carried by the wind across Cromwell Flat.” (Fig. 20).
As will be shown later, the distribution of the sand has had an important effect in modifying the vegetation of this flat.
Strong winds from the south-west also occur at all seasons, but these are generally moisture laden, and if they do not bring rain, they cause the higher levels to be shrouded by mists, especially in winter.
The effect of the wind in conjunction with the sand particles, is also seen in the disintegrating action which it has upon the dying Raoulia patches. These patches are a characteristic feature of the landscape, and lie close to the surface, where the sand blast action is greatest. At a certain age in the development of these circular patches, the central region dies, while the peripheral portion remains alive. The resistance of the central portion is lessened, and the constant bombardment of the sand particles has the effect of eroding the dead portion away (Fig. 5).

II.—Physiographic Factors:
The whole area is characterised by strong topographic relief. According to Park (1908, p. 15 et seq.), the valley had its origin as an area of subsidence involved in the greater “block mountain” system of Central Otago. Lacustrine and subsequent fluviatile deposition and erosion, combined with further faulting caused the valley to assume its present topography. It is flanked to the north-west by the Pisa Range, rising to 6300ft., and to the south-east by the Dunstan Range, rising to a maximum of 5320ft. At the lower end of the valley, to the south-west, lies the Carrick Range, about 5000ft. in height. The Clutha River, formed by the junction of the Upper Clutha and Kawarau Rivers, flows through the Dunstan Mountains in a narrow, deep gorge which turns off from the main valley about three miles from its south-west end. The floor of the valley is occupied by a system of terraces which clearly indicate the intermittent lowering of the base level of erosion.
The north face of the Dunstan Range is remarkable for its apparent barrenness. It is an excellent example of the influence of physiographic features in determining plant covering. The slopes are exceedingly steep, and characterised by immense outcrops of the mica-schist rock, of which the range is composed. The soil varies in thickness in different places. On the ridges and slopes it may be absent altogether, the surface being covered by angular stones weathered from the rocks above, owing to the daily extremes of temperature to which these rocks are exposed. On the other more level places, and especially at the bottom of the steep gullies, the soil may attain a depth of many feet. All gradations between these extremes may be present.
The flank of the range in question faces in a northerly direction and is thus exposed to the full glare of the sun. In summer, the heat of the surface of the ground is intense, often so hot that the stones cannot be touched with the bare hand. Buxton (1924) has made actual measurements of the heat attained on the actual surface of deserts, where it may be supposed that seeds must lie. He obtained temperatures of 60° C. (140° F.), where the shade temperature was 38° C. (100° F.). He points out that “reflected radiant heat is a factor with which desert fauna and flora have to reckon, especially in valleys.” As shade temperatures of between 90° F. and 100° F. are common in summer in the Cromwell district, then it is reasonable to suppose that the surface of the ground would probably attain temperatures corresponding to those cited by Buxton—i.e., 140° F.
On account of the deep dissection of the main range by lateral valleys, certain slopes are much more exposed to the sun than others. The character of the plant covering in the shady slopes is consequently different from that of the sunny slopes. On the sunny slopes, the Raoulia patches are often the only occupants, with the addition of certain small annuals in winter and spring. On the shady slopes, the Raoulia patches are much closer together, and the annuals appear more abundantly. Comparison of the Dunstan side of the valley with the Pisa side, whose slope is towards the south, gives some idea

of the influence which the direction of the slope has had upon the plant covering. Both slopes in the past have been subjected to, the same treatment as regards burning, stocking, and depredations of rabbits, but the Pisa side shows little of the depletion which so characterises the Dunstan side. The nature of the underlying rock is the same, the climatic factors are similar. Presumably, the direction of the slope has been chiefly instrumental in causing the difference in vegetation.
III.—Edaphic Factors:
The Dunstan and Pisa Ranges are composed of the same micaschist rock which characterises a very large area of Central Otago. The soil derived from it is very fertile, as evidenced by the excellent crops which are obtained when irrigation is intelligently practised. The floor of the valley is largely occupied by fluviatile and lacustrine gravels. These are covered by a fertile soil of an average thickness of about a foot, which requires only sufficient irrigation to bring it into productivity. The soil covering in certain places is, however, very thin, and on the Cromwell Flat itself, is composed of drifting sand, which makes cultivation difficult.
The extreme permeability of the gravel beds causes the moisture that is precipitated to be quickly absorbed. The difficulty of getting water to the higher terraces, combined with the thirsty nature of the sub-soil has been instrumental in discouraging cultivation on these terraces. The soil itself is light in colour and texture, containing little humus, and consequently dries out very quickly.
On the lower terraces bordering the river, certain small areas of ground occur which are almost entirely bare of vegetation except for two species of plants, Chenopodium glaucum and Atriplex buchanani. These areas are composed of a very fine alkaline soil, derived as a concentrated decomposition product of the mica-schist rocks. On the surface a whitish crust forms in dry weather, the composition of which is given in Table VI.* The composition of the soil at a depth of six inches is given in Table VII.
[The section below cannot be correctly rendered as it contains complex formatting. See the image of the page for a more accurate rendering.]
| Moisture | 4.2 | |
| Loss on ignition— | ||
| (organic matter and water in combination) | 4.4 | |
| Soluble salts— | ||
| Sodium chloride | 3.7 | 22.0 |
| Potassium chloride (trace) | ||
| Sulphates (mostly of Sodium) | 16.1 | |
| Sodium carbonate and other salts (by difference) | 2.2 | |
| Insoluble oxides | 69.4 | |
| 100.0 |
Table VI.—Composition of surface crust of alkali patches.
[Footnote] * The author is indebted to Mr H. A. A. Aitken, M.Sc., Chem. Dept., Otago University, for the analyses given in Tables VI and VII.

[The section below cannot be correctly rendered as it contains complex formatting. See the image of the page for a more accurate rendering.]
| Loss on ignition (moisture and organic matter) | 5.15 | |
| Soluble Salts— | ||
| Sodium chloride | .27 | .34 |
| Other salts | .07 | |
| Insoluble oxides | 94.51 | |
| 100.00 |
Table VII.—Composition of soil of alkali patches at a depth of six inches.
It will be seen that the concentration of salts in the upper crust is excessive (22%), and far higher than that in the deeper soil (0.34%). A similar concentration of salts in the upper crust has been found in more extensive alkali soils in other countries. Nevertheless, even a concentration of 0.34% in the deeper soil, where it may be supposed that the plant has its absorbing system, is a higher concentration of salts than is found in ordinary soils. Only plants which can tolerate such an amount of salts in the soil, can thrive in such places.
On the Dunstan Range, below the 3000-foot level, the soil which remains on the surface, has probably derived the humus it now possesses from the decay of plants which formerly covered this part of the range. At the present time, almost the only plant which can be considered to contribute appreciably to the humus is Raoulia lutescens, but it cannot be said that the addition so made occurs in any quantity.
The Water Supply of the Soil.—On the slopes of the ranges, the water available for plant life depends almost entirely upon the scanty rainfall. The nature of the underlying metamorphic rock precludes any possibility of the existence of springs or water-table. Of course, fissures in the rock hold a certain amount of moisture, and it is upon this water that most of the very occasional perennials which occur can be reckoned to depend. As mentioned in the section on climate, the rain which falls comes in sudden, heavy showers, most of which runs off rapidly into the precipitous gullies, and subsequently into the Clutha River. The lack of plant covering must also lessen the amount of water retention. The surface of the soil is generally baked hard, so that there is no mulch to retard evaporation under a hot sun.
On the terraces, on the other hand, the presence of a water-table at varying distances from the surface allows deep-rooting plants to obtain water from its capillary fringe. Examination of the actual depth of the water-table in various places was too extensive a task to carry out, but certain observations were made while excavating root-systems. In one case especially, the response of the roots to the presence of the capillary fringe was found to be very striking (Fig. 11). The well-known water-holding capacity of fine sand has also been partly responsible in determining plant distribution. This point will be elaborated in a later section.

IV.—Biotic Factors:
The valley of the Upper Clutha, especially upon the Dunstan side, forms along with other regions of Central Otago, a very striking case of the influence of biotic factors in determining the character of the plant covering. The communities which now exist below the 3000-foot level (or thereabouts) can definitely be stated to owe their present nature largely to the destructive influence of fire, sheep, and rabbits, indirectly through the influence of man.
This conclusion can be arrived at not only by a critical study of existing vegetation, but is amply substantiated by the known history of the area as described by settlers of sixty and seventy years ago.
The lower slopes of the Dunstan Range before the occupation by the sheep farmer were covered by a community dominated by the tussock grass. Now, tussocks (Poa caespitosa and Festuca Novae-Zelandiae) grow only in shady or inaccessible places and alongside water-races. The ground is irregularly dotted with the intensely xerophytic cushions or patches of the close-growing Raoulia lutescens. A more complete description of the community is given later.
As Cockayne points out (1922, p. 328), the methods of sheep farming on other tussock grassland communities of New Zealand were, and still are, much the same as those used in the area under consideration. Burning, stocking, and rabbit infestation were as wholesale elsewhere as here. Yet only those parts of Central Otago which are subjected to such a semi-arid climate, the hottest and driest in New Zealand, have undergone depletion. That climatic and physiographic factors finally have the determining influence on the existing vegetation can be shown by the fact that, above 3000 feet, where the rainfall increases, although sheep and rabbits have access to these altitudes, depletion ceases. On sunny faces of gullies in the depleted zone, depletion is complete, while on the opposite shady faces, there are often many tussocks.
The harsh leaves of the tussocks do not afford very palatable feed for sheep, and so the early sheep farmers were in the habit of running indiscriminate fires through the grassland, to take advantage of the more succulent green leaves produced in spring. This burning was carried out year after year, the cumulative effect of which has proved disastrous.
In addition, the runholder stocked his land beyond its capacity, with little regard for the future. Finally, the coming of the rabbits fifty years ago added to the destruction. Their propensity for rapid reproduction and their voracious appetites are well known—“With an eminently favourable climate, abundant food, and a soil suitable for burrowing or rocks in plenty for their homes, these animals increased enormously, so that with them and the sheep, the country became greatly overstocked. Every plant at all palatable was eaten to the ground; the depleted area ascended higher and higher; those perennials alone could survive which either were not eaten at all or were furnished with far-extending underground stems, and

possessed the power of rapid growth after being cropped close. Then there were annual species, which possessed great and rapid powers of increase by means of seed, or, in the case of such plants as die yearly to the ground, by far creeping subterranean stems. It is the addition of the last three categories to the pasture—mostly foreign plants, with sorrel and wild geranium the most important as feed, whose advent in quantity has been made possible by the new ground—which has rendered the sheep runs still productive, bringing in far more good feed than the general aspect of the depleted areas would lead one to imagine.” (Cockayne, 1922, p. 329).
The ubiquitous Raoulia, with its compacted habit, offered no food whatever to the rabbit or sheep, nor was it affected by burning. Foweraker (1917) has shown that its leaf surface, reduced to a minimum, protected by woolly hairs, gives it ample protection against excessive transpiration, and the water storage cells in its leaves gives it power to tide over drought periods. Its abundant winged fruits (it is a Composite) confers upon it efficient powers of dispersal. Its extensive, fibrous, and deep system of roots, occupying the greatest possible amount of soil, gives it power to withstand long periods of draught. All these characteristics combined enabled it to take possession rapidly of the ground made bare by the destruction of the tussock covering. It is dominant now on account of the inability of other plants to withstand the concerted influence of unfavourable factors, not because it occupies ground which might otherwise support tussock-grassland.
Cockayne (1922) has shown that fencing of small areas from stock and rabbits resulted in the rapid regeneration of the original plant covering only when the stumps or underground parts of these plants remained alive in the ground. Where all the plants were quite dead, regeneration took place very slowly by natural spread of seeds on wind-swept areas. But where seeds of both native and introduced plants were sown and raked in, these were able to germinate and establish themselves on the experimental areas.
At the present time, due to more intelligent farming, stocking is not quite so heavy, and rabbits have been greatly reduced in numbers. But, except on the Pisa south-facing side of the valley, no very appreciable difference in the amount of tussock can be observed.
While examining the locality, an interesting piece of evidence bearing upon the composition of the original vegetation was discovered. As previously mentioned, the range is characterised by great outcrops of rock, of very varying shapes and sizes. One such rock was discovered which possessed a more or less flat top. This flat top of the rock was obviously out of reach of sheep and rabbits, was also safe from fire, and could only be scaled with difficulty. On its summit were found eleven species of plants, excluding several mosses and lichens, growing in close association on a layer of soil. These were as follows:—
- Poa Colensoi Hook (tussock growth form).
- Poa caespitosa Forst (tussock growth form).
- Pimelea aridula Cockayne (small shrub).

- Pimelea Poppelwelli Petrie (small shrub).
- Gaultheria antipoda Forst (small rigid shrub).
- Cassinia fulvida Hook (shrub 2–6ft. high).
- Senecio bellidioides Hook (herb).
- Senecio Haastii Hook (herb).
- Celmisia gracilenta Hook (herb).
- Luzula campestris (var?) (herb).
- Cheilanthes Sieberi Kunze (fern).
Now most of these species can be found growing as isolated specimens in crevices and more or less inaccessible parts of the rocks of the district, but their association here into a continuous covering on an area of about seven or eight square yards is a striking indication of the community which can and does exist when the influence of animals and fire is removed.
A feature of the lower parts of the gullies is the presence of old dried-up water-races, which were originally dug by gold miner twenty or thirty years ago. Even though some of these have been dry many years, they often show a growth of tussock along their beds and margins, illustrating the fact that when this plant is able to establish (on account of the temporarily increased water supply), it can live successfully on return of the natural conditions, provided there is a sufficient thickness of soil, and extraneous biotic factors are inoperative.
This evidence indicates that regeneration by natural processes, if possible, will necessarily occur only after a long period of time, and only if the biotic factors are entirely eliminated. The original plant covering was the result of perhaps hundreds of years of growth and decay. Man's influence reversed the process in a few years, and the return to the original state can occur only after the lapse of a very considerable period of time.
Observations Upon the Vegetation.
It is not intended to give here a complete account of the species which comprise the plant covering, but only to mention certain relevant observations.
The area can be divided into four main regions according to the plants which give each its distinct facies. These are as follows:—
- (1) The Dunstan Lower Slopes.
- (2) The Pisa Lower Slopes.
- (3) The Terraces.
- (4) The Cromwell Sandy Flat.
These divisions are based upon the broader features of the associations only. Various factors have modified the vegetation of certain localised places very considerably. For instance, along the banks of the Clutha River are immense heaps of “tailings” produced by the gold-dredges of twenty years ago. These have completely covered up much alluvial land, and formed large areas of barren shingle—heaps

of stones quite bare of vegetation in some places, and in others slowly being colonised by certain species. The succession on such places would be a study in itself. Again, there are a few places near the river which are subject to periodic flooding and which show a typical swamp association—as evidenced by consociations of Typha augustifolia and Juncus spp. Such localised places do not enter into this discussion.
I.—The Dunstan Lower Slopes:
An account of the severe factors of the habitat acting upon the association which covers this region has already been given.
The dominant species is Raoulia lutescens Beauv. The silvery green flat cushions of this plant (locally known as “scabweed”) comprise the striking feature of the landscape. At all seasons of the year they retain the same appearance, seemingly unaffected by the changes in temperature or humidity. On steep and gentle slopes alike, their deep, fibrous roots afford ample anchorage and a sufficiency of water, while their reduced leaf-surface brings transpiration to a minimum. As mentioned above, the frequency with which the patches occur differs on sunny and shady slopes. Measurements of the diameter of a number of patches were taken during March, and these were checked again in August—six months later. It was found that during this period one patch had increased in average diameter by about one inch while others had increased by ¼-inch to ¾-inch. It is unfortunate that the observations could not have extended over a longer period—at least a year—so as to obtain more reliable results. Moreover, these measurements represent the growth during the slower growing period. However, supposing that one takes a conservative estimate of an average annual growth of one inch in diameter, one might well suppose, considering the numerous patches present, that in a very few years they would coalesce to form a continuous carpet. This is actually found in some south-facing slopes, but over the greater part it never occurs. The reason seems to be that after a certain maximum is reached, the patch begins to die away in the centre. Thus its resistance is lowered, and the wind aided by small stones and sand, soon erodes the dead portion away, blowing away also the humus which had collected beneath. Thus the original large patch becomes broken up sometimes into two, three, or four smaller patches, representing the peripheral living portions, and new ground is laid bare.
Considering the open exposed ground, that is, excluding such places as shady crevices between the large outcrops of rocks, and the rocks themselves—different seasonal aspects can be distinguished in the association.
Prevernal and Vernal Aspect.—As noted above, the Raoulia patches are present at all seasons, and maintain much the same appearance. But during the period between June and September, the ground between the patches becomes quite green with thousands of seedlings of such plants as Poa Maniototo Petrie, a small tufted

grass, Agrostis alba Linn. (introduced), Stellaria gracilenta Hook., a wiry herb, and Mysosurus aristatus Benth., a small herb with radical leaves.
Early Aestival Aspect.—From November to January the annuals which had germinated previously, develop and produce their seed. The abundant white starry capitula and winged fruits of Raoulia lutescens are produced during December and January.
Late Aestival and Autumnal Aspect.—From February to May the effect of the hot summer period shows itself, and the annuals are for the most part either dead or severely desiccated. Poa Maniototo persists as dead or almost dead tufts between the scabweed. Only the scabweed appears to be alive, and the soil between the patches is more or less bare. Small cushions of Colobanthus brevisepalus T. Kirk, one to two inches in diameter, appear to persist actually on the scabweed patches all the year round.
There are a number of shrubs which grow on the slopes. However, they are found only dotted here and there, and never occur in such numbers as to lend any distinct facies to the association. The commonest of these is Hymenanthera dentata var. alpina T. Kirk, an almost leafless, densely interlaced and low-growing shrub. Olearia odorata Petrie, O. lineata Cockayne, and also Sophora tetraptera Mill, are generally to be found in the more shady gullies, where they may attain the height of shrubby trees.
The moss and lichen flora is extensive, the abundance of bare, jagged rocks offering an excellent holdfast. The most abundant moss is Grimmia trichophylla, growing in small rounded cushions, its “leaves” covered with small silky hairs.
II.—The Pisa Lower Slopes:
It has been observed previously that these slopes face in a southerly direction, and that there is little of the depletion which so characterises the opposite side of the Clutha Valley. With the exception of but a few, all the plants growing on the Dunstan side are also present on the Pisa side of the valley, but they are present here with others, in far greater amount. Except on the barest tops of the ridges between the lateral gullies, Raoulia species are rare. The tussock grasses (Poa caespitosa and Poa Colensoi) are specially abundant, and in most places the silver tussock (P. caespitosa) forms a continuous covering, becoming the dominant species. It has already been stated that this difference in vegetation is considered to be in direct relation to physiographic features.
III.—The Terraces:
The terraces occupy the greater part of the floor of the Clutha Valley at this part of it (Fig. 20). They are composed of great thicknesses of fluviatile and lacustrine gravels which for the most part are covered by a layer of light-coloured soil of an average depth of about one foot. The gravels are absorbent and quickly take up the moisture which is precipitated.

The association, except where man's activities have completely changed it, shows definite seasonal aspects. During the prevernal and vernal periods the dominant species are Erodium cicutarium L'Herit, and Rumex acetosella Linn.; both introduced plants. The latter is present almost the whole year round. Associated with these species is a very abundant lichen which has not been identified. This lichen is peculiar in being, quite unattached, and in cartwheel tracks and slight depressions it may be scooped up in handfuls. No apothecia could be discovered upon it. Almost as frequent as the Erodium are dead stumps of the tiny Poa Maniototo Petrie. Patches of a species of Polytrichum are also common.
During the early aestival period, the continued hot weather causes the lichen to dry up and disappear. Erodium cicutarium becomes less dominant, and Rumex acetosella to a large degree persists, giving to the ground a reddish tint.
Over the greater part of the terraces, especially wherever the top soil becomes thinner, the patches of Raoulia lutescens and R. australis occur dotted here and there. In places where the top soil is very thin or even absent altogether, these plants may be the sole occupants, but for the most part they do not occur to nearly the same extent as on the lower slopes of the Dunstan Range.
In certain places Geranium sessiliflorum Cav. may become an important member of the turf. The character of the gravel is apparently very suitable for the development of its characteristic surface and deep sets of absorbing roots. Its comparative rarity on the Dunstan slopes may be explained on similar grounds—i.e., that a sufficiently great depth of soil is not present to allow of the development of the deeper roots of this type of root-system.
Hymenanthera dentata var. alpina occurs as compact low shrubs (Fig. 22).
Poa caespitosa is conspicuous by its absence. This would seem to be related to the character of its root-system. The species is distinctly perennial and requires a certain minimum of moisture in the surface soil all the year round, owing to its shallow root-habit. The absorbent nature of the sub-soil causes the top soil to dry out in summer very easily, and thus the moisture content is too low to allow this tussock to live, except in shady places, or where for any other reason the amount of surface moisture is maintained. It will be shown in considering the Cromwell sandy flat that other reasons do here permit the establishment of Poa caespitosa.
IV.—The Cromwell Sandy Flat:
It has been shown under the section on Climatic Factors that this area is for the most part covered with a layer of drifting sand derived from the sandy faces of the terraces near Deadman's Point. The area which is so covered can be seen by reference to the map (Fig. 20).
A combination of factors has here brought about the dominance of Poa caespitosa. The root-habit of this species is a shallow one,

and it is well known that fine sand retains moisture quite near the surface very efficiently. It is noteworthy that wherever the thickness of sand is sufficient to allow of the retention of surface moisture, then Poa caespitosa becomes dominant. Where sand is lacking on this flat, Raoulia lutescens is dominant. Gradations can be found where the two species are evenly mixed, owing to the depth of sand being just enough to allow the growth of a few plants of Poa caespitosa and not enough either to bury the scabweed or to permit the tussock to become dominant over it.
The sand which is derived from the terrace face is not evenly distributed over the flat. In one place especially, the wind causes the sand to be distributed in a narrow strip over the flat, extending for about a mile. The surface of the ground of this strip does not appear sandy, being covered with a thin layer of humus derived from the dead leaves of the tussock, and when the strip of tussock was first observed, the reason of its occurrence was not apparent. But when the character of the root-habit of Poa caespitosa was ascertained, and actual examination of the top soil of the strip was made, the cause of this peculiar distribution became evident. Figure 23 shows the abrupt ecotone between Poa caespitosa and Raoulia lutescens where this strip is situated. By digging it was found generally that wherever the depth of sand over the ground was more than 6 to 9 inches, then the tussock was able to become dominant over the scabweed.
Some areas of the flat where the wind has removed both soil and sand are completely bare of vegetation except for Raoulia lutescens (Fig. 5). Others approach the character of the terrace association, with R. lutescens, Poa Maniototo Rumex acetosella, and Erodium cicutarium the leading species.
Where the deposition of sand has been particularly heavy, drifting dunes have been formed. On such dunes Ammophila arenaria (marram grass) has been introduced, and Figure 24 shows it in association with Poa caespitosa.
The Leaf Anatomy of some of the Plants.
With a view towards gaining a fuller insight into the relation between the plants and their environment, the leaf anatomy of some of the species whose root-systems have been described, was studied. It was considered sufficient for the purpose required to make transverse microtome sections of the leaves. Five species were thus examined. Of these, the leaves of Poa caespitosa and Lepidium sisymbrioides, as well as the cladode of Carmichaelia Petriei, are well equipped with those modifications generally accounted xerophytic. Thick cuticle and sunken stomata are common to all three, while in addition Poa caespitosa exhibits a strong inrolling of the leaf. Hymenanthera dentata var. alpina and Geranium sessiliflorum on the other hand, show no marked xerophytic adaptations in their leaf anatomy. A very full description of the autecology of Raoulia lutescens has been given by Foweraker (1917), and a figure of a transverse section of the leaf of R. tenuicaulis, which is similar to

R. lutescens, is supplied. The white tomentum and development of large-celled water storing tissue of this leaf can be interpreted as definite xerophytic adaptations.
It would seem, then, that not all the plants habitually thriving under semi-arid conditions display in the anatomy of their leaves devices for the reduction of transpiration.
Conclusions and Discussion.
In the foregoing, the root-habits of seven indigenous and one exotic species have been described. Although perhaps a greater number of examples would be a desideratum before drawing definite conclusions, yet those examined are the most characteristic of the dry area, and using some of the principles deduced by other investigators of root-systems, some conclusions can be formulated.
A classification of the root-systems of perennials based on physiological rather than systematic lines has been put forward by Cannon (1911, p. 87). He distinguishes three types, namely, the generalised type with taproot and laterals both well developed, and two specialised types, of which one has a prominent taproot and the other prominent laterals. He concludes that perennials with the generalised type of root-system have the widest local distribution, and those with a pronounced development of taproot have the most limited distribution. He also states that the specialised type of rootsystems of either form are changed little with environment, but the generalised roots are often extremely variable, ranging from a pronounced taproot to a marked development of the laterals, dependent on the soil characters and water relations.
Just how far these conclusions can be applied to the root-systems of the plants of the semi-arid districts of New Zealand cannot be properly ascertained until more data are accumulated. It is difficult to fit such a root-system as is possessed by Raoulia lutescens into the classification Cannon suggests, unless it is deemed to be a generalised one. On the basis of this classification, however, Carmichaelia Petriei, Hymenanthera dentata var. alpina, Geranium sessiliflorum, and Raoulia lutescens would be generalised types, while Lepidium sisymbrioides would be a specialised type, with prominence of the taproot.
Certainly in the examples of Carmichaelia Petriei which were excavated, the development of the laterals, in so far as their lateral extension was concerned, varied greatly in different stations, thus illustrating its adaptability. (Compare Figs. 11, 12, and 14). But it also has a limited local distribution—possibly on account of the influence of other factors, viz., the lack of any special means of dispersal of its heavy seeds. Hymenanthera dentata var. alpina, Geranium sessiliflorum, Poa caespitosa, and Raoulia lutescens have all a wide local distribution, and may be found on all depths of soil, and must therefore be capable of extreme variability. The character of their root habit is in accordance with this conclusion. Lepidium sisymbrioides, with its prominent taproot, is limited in distribution,

and it can be fairly certainly asserted that it would not occur except in soils which would allow such penetration of the taproot. Throughout New Zealand, Poa caespitosa thrives under a variety of climatic conditions. But in the semi-arid district, its moisture requirement in the surface soil is just at the point of balance between an adequacy and a deficiency. Any factor which tends to bring the soil moistur in the uppermost two feet of soil above a certain minimum, will favour the dominance of the tussock. A knowledge of its root habit gives a clearer insight into its distribution.
The presence of plants having a system of roots absorbing from the capillary fringe indicates the possibility of using on the terraces crop plants which are known to have a similar habit, e.g., lucerne. The difficulty with regard to this is that the young plants would need to be supplied with water by irrigation for two or three years until the deeper roots had been established. This has been the experience in certain parts of the U.S.A. (Meinzer 1927, p. 89). It appears that provided the lucerne is tided over the critical period in the first few years of its life, then satisfactory crops are returned without further irrigation. However, the author adds that “on lands where natural subirrigation has proved feasible, the soil and subsoil down to the water-table is a dark grey clay loam or sandy loam and a black loam derived largely from decomposed peat. Attempts to extend cultivation of subirrigated lucerne to adjoining areas where the subsoil is gravelly have not proved successful, although the depths to the ground water in these areas are no greater than in the area where success has been attained.”
It may be added, however, that the depths to ground water in the above mentioned region were from 9 to 15 feet. From the few observations made upon the soils of the Cromwell area, the depths of the capillary fringe at least, seems to be somewhat less than these figures, in one case 4 feet. This relative shallowness of the watertable might well discount the difficulty of the presence of a gravelly subsoil.
Three of the species examined were found to have distinct surface and deeper systems of absorbing roots, viz., Carmichaelia Petriei, Geranium sessiliflorum, and Hymenanthera dentata var. alpina. This character seems to be a distinct development in relation to the water supply of the soil.
The true definition of the term “xerophily” has been much discussed. (Delf, 1915). The older view was to class as xerophytes those plants with form and structure apparently adapted to reduce water loss by transpiration. But it has been proved that not all plants which grow in such places are so modified, and plants with thickened cuticle, sunken stomata, or succulent leaves are not exclusively characteristic of desert places. Two examples can be quoted from the present study, viz., Hymenanthera dentata var. alpina and Geranium sessiliflorum, neither of which has leaves highly modified to reduce transpiration.

It has also been shown that the idea that saline and moorland soils are “physiologically” dry is unfounded. Plants with succulent and selerophyllous leaf structure have been found to transpire freely. A calculation of the total leaf surface of Calluna (the Northern heath) puts it ahead of many mesophytes in its proportion of transpiring surface, and an examination of the amount of transpiration of the plant as compared with its absorbing system, shows Calluna to be able to lose water like a mesophyte, because in its natural habitat plenty of water is practically always available.
Delf (1915), after examining the evidence, concludes that “xerophily cannot be adequately defined in terms of habitat, of anatomy, or of physiology alone. It is rather a natural conception involving the total reaction of the plant environment. In general, it may be said that xerophilous plants are those which with the help of certain structural modifications can continue to perform their vital functions when exposed to climatic conditions involving atmospheric or edaphic drought or both. Atmospheric drought causes production of cuticle and often of more or less sclerotic subepidermal tissue. Edaphic drought may be met in at least three ways:—
1. By the development of a deep root-system penetrating to a constant water supply in the subsoil.
2. By the production of a generalised root-system with tissues which can develop very high osmotic pressures, so that absorption is possible even in air-dry soil.
3. By a superficial root-system with capacity to form adventitious collecting rootlets rapidly after rainfall. When there is a regular rainy period, however short, the superficial root-system is usually accompanied by the development of much aqueous tissue for water storage.
In the light of the definition given above, it becomes evident that no single character should be selected as an unfailing criterion of xerophily. All the characters of the plant should be taken into account; but even when this is done, the final proof should come from actual experiment.
It has been shown previously that the Cromwell district is subjected to both atmospheric and edaphic drought. In Raoulia lutescens we have a plant which probably owes its widespread occurrence to a combination of the above characters, i.e., a deep, generalised, and superficial root-system, as well as the development of an aqueous storage tissue. No experiments upon the actual water loss of this plant have ever been carried out, but it is possible that the amount transpired may be greater than would be supposed.
With regard to the other perennials which have been discussed in this paper, there can be little doubt that the consideration of their root habit in conjunction with their above-ground parts, shows them to be true xerophytes.

Summary.
1. This study was undertaken to determine the root habits of some of the plants of the Cromwell district, an area which can be considered fairly representative of the most arid region of New Zealand, with a view towards correlating the knowledge so gained with the character, distribution, and succession of the vegetation.
2. The investigation was carried out at intermittent intervals over a period of seven months, from February to September, 1928, during which time about 30 individual root-systems belonging to nine different species of plants were excavated.
3. The method of examination consisted in digging a trench alongside the plant, thus exposing a vertical face from which the roots could be dissected.
4. The roots of the dicotyledonous perennials were found to penetrate nowhere less than four feet, and in some cases more than six feet. The grass investigated (Poa caespitosa) penetrated to an average depth of three feet, with the bulk of its roots in the upper foot. The two annuals examined did not penetrate more than eighteen inches.
5. The dicotyledonous perennials showed a definite tendency to develop a deep and a surface system of absorbing roots. This can be interpreted as a response to the character of the environment.
6. The leaf anatomy of Hymenanthera dentata var. alpina, Geranium sessiliflorum, Lepidium sisymbrioides, Raoulia lutescens and Poa caespitosa are briefly described. Although some of these species may develop a very thick cuticle, others, notably the first two named, do not. The inference is that leaf anatomy alone is not a reliable criterion of xerophily.
7. The presence of plants having a system of roots absorbing moisture from the capillary fringe indicates the possibility of utilising on the terraces crop plants which have a similar habit.
8. The district can be divided into four main subdivisions, according to the communities which characterise them, viz.:
- (a) The Dunstan Lower Slopes.
- (b) The Pisa Lower Slopes.
- (c) The Terraces.
- (d) The Cromwell Sandy Flat.
The climatic factors are similar on all these divisions. Edaphic, physiographic, and biotic factors have been instrumental in causing the differences between them.
9. A study of root habit in conjunction with a knowledge of the above-ground parts of plants gives a fuller understanding of the problems of competition, succession, and distribution.

Literature Citations.
Betts, M. Winifred, 1919. Notes on the Autecology of Certain Plants of the Peridotite Belt, Nelson. Part I. Structure of Some of the Plants (No. 2). Trans. N.Z. Inst., vol. 51, pp. 136–56.
Buxton, P. A., 1924. The Temperature of the Surface of Deserts. Jour. Ecol., vol. 12, pp. 127–34.
Delf, E. Marion, 1915. The Meaning of Xerophily. Jour. Ecol., vol. 3, pp. 110–21.
Cannon, W. A., 1911. The Root Habits of Desert Plants. Carnegie Inst. Wash. Pub., 131.
Cockayne, L., 1921. Die Vegetation der Erde, vol. 14. The Vegetation of New Zealand. Leipzig, W. Engelmann.
—– 1922. An Economic Investigation of the Montane Tussock Grassland of New Zealand. XII. The Regrassing Experiments in Central Otago. N.Z. Jour. Agric., vol. 24, pp. 321–34; vol. 25, pp. 1–11 and pp. 129–44.
Foweraker, C. E., 1917. Notes from the Canterbury College Mountain Biological Station, Cass. No. 5. The Mat Plants, Cushion Plants, and allied forms of the Cass River Bed. Trans. N.Z. Inst., vol. 49, pp. 1–45.
Meinzer, O. E., 1927. Plants as Indicatois of Ground Water. U.S. Geol. Surv., Water Supply Paper, No. 577.
Park, J., 1908. Geology of the Ciomwell Subdivision. N.Z. Geol. Surv., Bul. 5.
Weaver, J. E., 1919. The Ecological Relations of Roots. Carnegie Inst. Wash. Pub., 286.


