
The Genus Erato in the Tertiary of New Zealand
[Read before the Auckland Institute, March 21, 1934; received by Editor. April 23, 1934; issued separately, September, 1935.]
A Review of the Neozelanic fossils belonging to the genus Erato has shown that to the already recorded forms (five in number) eight new species have now to be added. In consideration of the fact that Erato is a genus not particularly strong in species, one must regard it as having been quite well represented in the New Zealand Tertiary fauna. In the Neozelanic region it first appeared in Tahuian times, when it was represented by three species; in the ensuing Waiarekan one species is known, while two appear in Ototaran beds; its maximum strength is in Hutchinsonian faunas, where there are five species, of which four occur in the beds at Clifden; the Awamoan records a decline (three species), after which the line appears to have died out, for no records are so far known in either Pliocene or Recent Neozelanic faunas, though it occurs Recent in Australian waters.
Two distinct lineages are indicated, E. neozelanica Suter and E. waiauensis n.sp. falling apart from other species in size and certain other shell characters. Of the remainder possibly E. sepositum n.sp. represents another line of shells, typically of more slender form and with more elevated spire.
E. submorosa n.sp. and E. neozelanica Suter are the only species that pass from one stage to another. Submorosa is not uncommon in the Hutchinsonian at Clifden, and is found also, though not commonly, in the Awamoan beds at Target Gully and at Pukeuri. E. neozelanica also occurs in Waitakian, Hutchinsonian, and Awamoan faunas.
Genus Erato Risso.
Risso, 1826. Histoire naturelle des principales productions de l'Europe meridionale, vol. 4. p. 240.
Type (by monotypy): Voluta cypraeola Brocchi.
Erato is a genus of the Cypraeidae containing shells superficially resembling Marginella; but the denticulate character of both inner and outer lips, presence of columellar furrow, and absence of definite plaits on the pillar are characters showing quite obvious alliance with Cypraea. The Cypraeidae are not well represented in New Zealand, and it appears that of the three genera present Erato is the strongest in species.
Group A.
As has been stated, the New Zealand species seem to fall into three natural groups. Group A contains the bulk of the species, all small shells with inconspicuous spire and absence of fossula at base of columella.

| Spire exceedingly low, scarcely differentiated. | |
| Several columellar plications present. | |
| Shell small, about 4mm. high; beak quite short; inner lip finely denticulate throughout; spire scarcely perceptible, | antiqua |
| Adult shell larger and heavier, about 6 mm. high; beak rather more drawn out; inner lip not denticulate; spire much less obscure. | vulcania |
| Columellar plications absent. | |
| A single strong fold at base of columella, which is a continuation of the thickened rim of anterior notch of aperture. | accola |
| Spire quite distinctly raised above surface of posterior end of shell. Shell very small (about 3–5 mm. long), posterior margin of aperture considerably pouting. | submorosa |
| Shell larger, posterior margin of outer lip not unduly thrust out. | |
| Outer lip sculptured externally by four or five fine plications on anterior part of thickened rim. | senectus |
| Outer lip not sculptured by external plications. | |
| Body-whorl very full posteriorly; shell of heavy build, short, and stoutish. | |
| Denticulation coarse on outer lip (eight denticles present); inner lip with denticles along anterior half only. | waitakiensis |
| Denticulation very fine on outer lip (fifteen denticles present); inner lip with weak denticles along entire length. | clifdenensis |
| Body-whorl not unduly swollen behind; shell of lighter build, distinctly less squat. | |
| Columella broadly excavated below; outer lip thin and convex when viewed from front; aperture unduly wide for the genus. | tenuilabrum |
| Columella not excavated below, almost straight; aperture not unduly wide. | |
| Shell small, about 3 mm. high; denticles on inner lip subobsolete, their place taken by a ridge along entire lip. | marshalli |
| Shell larger, about 5 mm. high; neither denticles nor ridge present on inner lip. | pukeuriensis |
Erato antiqua Marshall.
1919. Erato antiqua Marshall. Trans. N.Z. Inst., vol. 51, p. 227, pl. 15, fig. 7.
Distinctive in the very low spire, which scarcely rises above the curvature of the posterior of the shell. Numerous regularly spaced denticles are present along almost the entire length of the inner lip, a feature not commented on by the author of the species. There are two light folds present at the base of the inner lip, the posterior one the more oblique.
Height, 4.5 mm.; width, 3.5 mm. (holotype).
The type is from Hampden. There is a single topotype in the writer's collection.
Type in Wanganui Museum.
Erato accola n.sp. (Fig. 1).
Shell of moderate size for the genus, not unlike E. antiqua in shape and build; but the inner and outer lips are quite parallel, and the spire slightly more in evidence, though scarcely disturbing the normal curvature of the posterior of the shell. The outer lip is

more finely dentate than that of antiqua, and at the base of the pillar there is but one fold, which is heavy and quite conspicuous. Denticles of inner lip weak, dying out at about half its length from anterior.
Height, 6.0 mm.; width, 4.0 mm.
Locality, greensands, McCullough's Bridge (Tahuian).
Type (unique) in writer's collection.
Separable at sight from the Hampden shell in being larger and in having a single strong ridge at base of inner lip.
Erato vulcania Marwick.
1926. Erato vulcania Marwick. Trans. N.Z. Inst., vol. 56, p. 314, pl. 72, fig. 25.
Two topotypes in the writer's collection agree entirely with Dr Marwick's illustration. In addition to the rudimentary denticles on inner edge of outer lip, referred to by Marwick, there are present on one of the topotypes several very weak denticles along anterior third of inner lip. Vulcania is a more heavily built species than either of the foregoing, with higher spire and suppressed denticles to inner and outer lips.
Height, 4.0 mm.; width, 3.0 mm. (holotype).
Localities—Lorne, near Oamaru (Waiarekan), type; Trig. M, near Oamaru, a single specimen.
Type in collection of New Zealand Geological Survey. Two topotypes in writer's collection.
The Trig. M shell is smaller than those from the type locality, but quite definitely referable to Dr Marwick's species. Recent collecting at this locality has brought to light a number of interesting fossils. For the present it is sufficient to note that a not insignificant number of species previously known only from Lorne have been found to form a strong element in the fauna of the beds at Trig. M, viz., Limatula trulla, Mantellum inconspicuum, Serpulorbis lornensis, Lornia limata, Clavatula humerosa, Uromitra lornense, Spirocolpus tophina, Zeacolpus lornensis, Erato vulcania, all of Marwick. In addition, the writer has Argalista n.sp. from both these localities.
Erato aff. vulcania Marwick.
A single specimen agreeing with E. vulcania in all respects, save that the spire is very much less prominent and a good deal more callused. Further collecting may show this feature not to be constant.
Locality, Trig. M, near Oamaru.
Specimen in writer's collection.
Erato senectus Murdoch.
1924. Erato senectus Murdoch. Trans. N.Z. Inst., vol. 55, p. 160, pl. 10, figs. 5, 6.
The shape of this shell is reminiscent of that of E. neozelanica Suter, but closer inspection shows a number of quite distinct characters. In both species the spire is strongly exsert, but senectus is a much smaller species with differently arranged plications at base of columella; has fewer, less distinct denticles on inner lip which

are well outside aperture and not so near edge of inner lip as are those of neozelanica; and five or six teeth-plications on a raised area along the anterior of the outside of outer lip. Neozelanica has a sunken area on pillar separating the columellar ridges from the first of the denticles of inner lip, a feature not present in senectus.
Height, 4.5 mm.; width, 3.25 mm. (holotype).
Locality, shell-bed, Target Gully, Oamaru (Awamoan).
Type in Wanganui Museum. Two topotypes have since been collected, one by Dr Finlay and the other by the writer.
Erato waitakiensis n.sp. (Fig. 2).
Shell of moderate size for the genus, spire forming a distinct conical elevation on posterior surface of shell; aperture rather sinuous, its borders curving in sympathy one with the other; outer lip heavily thickened, convex; inner lip with three very weak plications at base, above which are a number of weak denticles, present for only about half its length above the plications; furrow well seen extending along entire length of inner lip.
Height, 5.0 mm.; width, 3.5 mm.
Locality, Otiake (Waitakian).
Type (sole specimen) in writer's collection.
The denticles along outer lip are weak, low, widely spaced.
Erato clifdenensis n.sp. (Fig. 3).
General shape and build very close to that of E. waitakiensis n.sp., from which it is separable at a glance on account of its finely, regularly, and sharply dentate outer lip. The basal ridges (four in number) also are finer, and are succeeded behind by a row of small, distinct denticles along entire length of the inner lip. The anterior region of inner lip is straight, that of waitakiensis being broadly excavated.
Height, 5.0 mm.; width, 3.0 mm.
Locality, Clifden, Southland, band 7 (Hutchinsonian).
Type (sole specimen) in writer's collection.
Erato submorosa n.sp. (Fig. 4).
Shell small, spire distinct, posterior end of aperture well arched upwards and outwards; outer lip convex with numerous denticles; inner lip broadly excavated at about middle, five fine, close plications below, and weak denticles along border reaching almost to posterior end.
Height, 3.2 mm.; width, 2.1 mm.
Localities—Pukeuri (type) and Target Gully (Awamoan localities). Clifden, Southland, bands 6A, 6B, 6C; bed A, left side of river, and new road-cutting behind racecourse = band 7 of the beds along the river (Hutchinsonian).
Type in writer's collection.
In all, six specimens were obtained at Clifden, four at Pukeuri, and three at Target Gully. The shells from Clifden agree with those from Oamaru in all respects save that the denticles along the outer lip are rather less heavy and more numerous.

Erato tenuilabrum n.sp. (Fig. 5).
Shell small, spire distinctly elevated, body swollen, fairly rapidly contracted to beak; spire with little or no callus, sutures visible, not hidden by callus. Aperture wide, more open below than above, and making a strong shoulder posteriorly; outer lip about straight, thickened a little externally, but thin when seen from the front, and with nine or ten small, distinct denticles along its entire length; inner lip broadly excavated, with two or three weak plications in front, and denticles practically absent, not seen on most specimens, but faintly indicated on one or two.
Height, 4.2 mm.; width, 2.7 mm. (holotype).
Locality, Clifden, Southland, bands 6A, 6C (type), and beds A and B on left side of river. (Bed A = 6C on right side and bed B base of 7 on right side.) Hutchinsonian.
Type in writer's collection.
This species is represented by eighteen specimens in the writer's collection. The wide aperture and broadly concave inner lip with almost obsolete denticles serve to mark it out from related species.
Erato pukeuriensis n.sp. (Fig. 6)
Shell larger than that of tenuilabrum, with high spire and less squat body-whorl. The inner lip is almost straight, not excavated, the outer lip is thicker and almost straight when viewed from the front, its denticles not so sharp. Like tenuilabrum, it has three weak plications at base of columella, and denticles of inner lip obsolete. The thickened external rim of outer lip has several very faint indications of teeth plications in one or two places.
Height, 5.1 mm.; width, 2.0 mm. (holotype).
Locality, Pukeuri (Awamoan).
Type and a paratype in writer's collection.
Erato marshalli Marwick.
1929. Erato marshalli Marwick. Trans. N.Z. Inst., vol. 59, p. 922, fig. 56.
The writer has a topotype of this species, and it agrees closely with Dr Marwick's figure and description.
Height, 2.7 mm.; width, 1.9 mm. (holotype).
Locality, Chatton, near Gore (Ototaran).
Type in collection of New Zealand Geological Survey.
Group B.
The species admitted to this group have large shells with sharply pointed spire, which is but little callused; a thick, heavy outer lip, strongly dentate throughout its entire length; a strongly dentate ridge along inner lip; and fairly heavy plications at base of inner lip, separated from anterior end of dentate ridge by a more or less pronounced excavation on columella.
| Shell stoutish, of heavy build, body-whorl well rounded; outer lip convex when viewed from front; columellar excavation very distinct; denticles on inner lip reaching to posterior third. | neozelanica |

| Shell more slender, of rather lighter build, body-whorl not so inflated behind, drawn out more in front; outer lip practically straight when viewed from the front; columellar excavation not so pronounced; denticles along whole length of inner lip behind plications. | waiauensis |
Erato neozelanica Suter.
1917. Erato neozelanica Suter. N.Z. Geol. Surv., Pal. Bull., No. 5, p. 12, pl. 3, figs. 6, 7.
1924. Erato neozelanica Suter. Murdoch, Trans. N.Z. Inst., vol. 55, p. 160, pl. 10, fig 4.
Neozelanica is now on record from Target Gully (type), Awamoan; Blue Cliffs, South Canterbury, Hutchinsonian; and Otiake, Waitakian (specimens in writer's collection); Okehu (Murdoch, loc. cit., p. 160). The Blue Cliffs shell matches the type perfectly.
Height, 19 mm.; width, 13 mm. (holotype).
Type in Otago University, Dunedin.
Erato waiauensis n.sp. (Fig. 7).
Shell large and very similar at first glance to neozelanica. It can readily be distinguished, however, by its more attenuate beak and less inflated body behind. The outer lip is straighter, the depression on columella immediately behind the plication is not so well differentiated, and there are denticles along the whole length of inner lip behind the depression. The disposition of the columellar plications is also different in the two species.
Height, 15.0 mm.; width, 9.0 mm. (holotype).
Locality—Clifden, Southland, beds A and C on left side of river, one specimen from each. Bed A = 6C on right side; bed C = base of 7 on right side (Hutchinsonian).
Type in writer's collection.
Group C.
Shell small, spire high for Erato, body fairly long and narrow. The single species located in this group bears a striking resemblance superficially to Marginella fraudulenta Suter.
Erato sepositum n.sp. (Fig. 8).
Shell small, spire well elevated, body long and tapering to a narrow, well-drawn-out beak. Outer lip convex, appreciably thickened, its inner edge bearing along entire length fine, close denticles; inner lip broadly concave below, several fine plications at base of columella; denticles not present on inner lip, but a distinct ridge running along its entire length, the parietal wall flat to lightly concave on inside of this ridge.
Height, 4.5 mm.; width, 2.8 mm.
Locality, greensands, McCullough's Bridge (Tahuian).
Type (sole specimen) in writer's collection.

Fig. 1.—Erato accola n.sp. Holotype.
Fig. 2.—Erato waitakiensis n.sp. Holotype.
Fig. 3.—Erato clifdenensis n sp. Holotype.
Fig. 4.—Erato submorosa n.sp. Holotype.
Fig. 5.—Erato tenuilabrum n.sp. Holotype.
Fig. 6.—Erato pukeuriensia n.sp. Holotype.
Fig. 7.—Erato waiauensis n.sp. Holotype.
Fig. 8.—Erato sepositum n.sp. Holotype. All figures show the specimens enlarged 12.3 diameters.
