Go to National Library of New Zealand Te Puna Mātauranga o Aotearoa
Volume 68, 1938-39
This text is also available in PDF
(547 KB) Opens in new window
– 390 –

A Phase Rule Study of the System: Na2O-V2O5-H2O.

[Read before the Auckland Institute, September 21, 1938; received by the Editor, August 1, 1938; issued separately, December, 1938.]

Since vanadium occupies the next position to phosphorus in the fifth group of the Periodic Classification, in its quinquevalent state it offers certain analogies to the corresponding phosphates, their similarity frequently being emphasised by reference to the ortho, pyro and metavanadates, Na3VO4, Na4V2O7 and NaVO3 respectively. It should not be forgotten, however, that acidification of solutions of the latter salt produces a marked yellow coloration which has been ascribed correctly to the formation in solution of a polyvanadate of the type: Na2O, xV2O5,yH2O, x being greater than unity, i.e., the polyvanadate is richer than the meta salt in respect to the acidic radical. Unfortunately, there is no agreement as to the precise composition of this salt, at least twenty different polyvanadates having been described, with a ratio of Na2O: V2O5, varying from 2:3 to 1:4, depending on the conditions attending their isolation. The methods employed in their preparation have almost invariably consisted in adding a weak acid to a metavanadate solution so as to buffer the solution between pH3 and pH6 and then crystallizing by evaporation. No study of this apparently complicated problem had been made on the basis of the Phase Rule and we, therefore, thought it worth while to make such an investigation. The work has been carried out during the last four years, but recently Kiehl and Manfredo (1937) have published the results of a similar investigation of the isotherm at 30°C. Publication of our results is, nevertheless, desirable because (1) in general the conclusions of the American workers are confirmed, (2) our analytical method is, we believe, superior, (3) our isotherm refers to 25°C. and (4) we come to a different conclusion with regard to the nature of the stable polyvanadate.

Method of Analysis.

Vanadium was always determined by the accurate permanganate titration of the sulphur dioxide reduced solution after removal of the excess of sulphur dioxide by carbon dioxide. Sodium was estimated as follows: Britton and Robinson (1930) have shown that the action of silver nitrate solution in excess on a vanadate of sodium gives a precipitate in which the ratio of Ag2O/V2O5 is exactly that of the Na2O/V2O5 in the original salt. Thus if a mixture of Na4V2O7 (or 2Na2O, V2O5) and NaVO3 (or Na2O, V2O5) is made in such proportions that the total composition corresponds to 1.5 Na2O, V2O5 then the first action of silver nitrate is to precipitate the less soluble silver pyrovanadate; but if the reagent is added in excess, the residual vanadate is precipitated as silver metavanadate and the composition of the whole precipitate corresponds to 1.5 Ag2O, V2O5. The analytical method therefore consisted of adding excess of silver nitrate solution, filtering the silver vanadate precipitate, washing

– 391 –

with cold water, dissolution in ammonia and determination of silver by gravimetric analysis of this solution after acidification with sulphuric acid. Duplicate analyses would agree as closely as 0.02% on both Na2O and V2O5 determinations. If the sample for analysis were more alkaline than the orthovanadate, standard sulphuric acid was added in known amount to bring the solution between the ortho and meta salt in composition. Similarly if the sample were more acid than the meta salt sufficient standard alkali was added to produce a colourless solution.

Equilibria with the colourless vanadates.

It will be convenient to describe first the equilibrium at 25°. between the aqueous phase and solid phases of the colourless ortho, pyro and metavanadates. These salts were prepared by fusion of vanadium pentoxide and sodium hydroxide in different proportions and the finely ground salt was then stirred with water for a period of one to three weeks, employing a mercury seal stirrer to exclude air. The thermostat was maintained at 25°±.01. In some cases solid sodium hydroxide was also added to produce a more alkaline mixture. After setting, samples of the liquid phase were withdrawn by filtration through glass wool into a pipette and the solid was sampled by rapid filtration through a sintered glass filter and the “wet residue” analysed. Analyses of 30 pairs of liquid and “wet solid” phases are given as weight percentages in Table I and plotted on the usual triangular diagram in Fig. I.

– 392 –

[The section below cannot be correctly rendered as it contains complex formatting. See the image of the page for a more accurate rendering.]

Table I.
The System Na2O–V2O5–H2O At 25°.
Liquid Phase. Solid Phase. Solid.
% Na2O % V2O5 % Na2O % V2O5
40.33 0.7 47.07 0.05 NaOH,H2O.
40.31 0.20 48.22 0.15
40.12 0.36 49.46 0.20
40.27 0.56 43.94 2.96 NaOH,H2O + Na3VO4,7H2O.
37.25 1.01 33.59 14.51 Na3VO4,7H2O.
35.71 32.82 14.20
29.63 0.21 29.41 19.79
26.32 0.20 28.34 17.77
25.35 0.22 28.33 19.00
24.38 0.28 27.07 16.21
10.56 1.43 16.36 11.50 Na3VO4,12H2O.
9.26 1.41 16.26 10.96
9.12 1.87 16.16 11.40
7.96 3.52 17.03 13.96
9.02 6.42 17.45 15.54
10.13 10.58 16.64 16.21
11.02 12.19 15.98 16.32
11.82 14.05 16.24 17.77
12.80 16.97 15.20 20.53 Na3VO412H2O + Na4V2O7,18H2O.
11.26 14.72 16.72 24.35 Na4V2O7,18H2O.
10.21 14.51 15.78 23.62
11.16 17.80 15.79 24.26
15.66 26.81 17.38 27.97
12.01 23.77 12.46 24.99 NaVO3,2H2O.
11.57 23.62 19.76 53.26
6.16 14.93 21.34 62.48
2.98 10.38 12.36 37.94
3.41 11.70 11.65 38.57
4.48 14.84
4.85 16.85 NaVO3,2H2O + Polyvanadate.

By drawing tie-lines on the triangular diagram it can be seen that at least five solid phases are stable at 25° in very alkaline solution NaOH,H2O is the solid phase, but the addition of a very small amount of vanadium pentoxide suffices to bring about a transition to Na3VO4,7H2O, a compound which is stable only in presence of an excess of alkali and which would recrystallize from its own solution as the dodecahydrate. The tie-lines are sufficient to characterize it as Na3VO4,7H2O, the formula given by Hall (1887), and not Na3VO4, 8H2O given by Baker (1885). Further addition of vanadium pentoxide leads to Na3VO4,12H2O, the pyrovanadate Na4V2O7,18H2O and the metavanadate NaVO3,2H2O; the tie-lines for the last salt, not drawn in the diagram, show, in agreement with McAdam and Pierle (1912), that the dihydrate and not the anhydrous salt is stable at 25°. The diagram affords no evidence for the stable existence at 25° of the compounds 4Na2O,V2O5,26(or 30)H2O obtained by Ditte (1887), Na3VO4,16H2O by Roscoe (1871), Na3VO4,10H2O by Baker (1885) or Na4V2O7,8H2O by Ditte (1887).

After the appearance of the paper by Kiehl and Manfredo (1937) we made a special search for the compound Na3VO4,2½H2O, which they found to be stable at 30°. We were able, after stirring for a month, to obtain three sets of points whose tie-lines passed approximately through the point corresponding to this compound.

– 393 –

The following were the analytical data obtained:—

Liquid Phase. Solid Phase.
% Na2O % Na2O % V2O5
38.27 38.82 12.64
38.20 39.33 12.41
37.98 38.44 14.93

Experimental work in this region is very difficult; moreover, this hydrate is stable over only a small range of solution concentration; this makes it impossible for the tie-lines to converge on the solidus point through a large angle and hence it is not possible to locate the composition of the compound accurately. The data are, however, sufficient to show that the compound is neither the dihydrate nor the trihydrate and that the formula Na3VO4,2½H2O given by Kiehl and Manfredo is likely to be correct.

Preparation of Polyvanadates.

A polyvanadate to which we give the formula 4Na2O,7V2O5, 33H2O and which we shall refer to as the 4:7 salt, was prepared in a number of ways:—

1.

By boiling an excess of vanadium pentoxide in sodium carbonate solution. The boiling should be continued for a short time only (about ten minutes), as prolonged boiling is apt to form the metavanadate; a large residue of the brown flocculent pentoxide is always left. Filtration yields a deep red solution from which efflorescent orange-red crystals are deposited on spontaneous evaporation at room temperature. Fusion of excess pentoxide with sodium carbonate gave only the colourless metavanadate.

2.

After boiling an excess of pentoxide with sodium hydroxide, the filtrate on evaporation yielded mainly the metavanadate mixed with a few red crystals which analysis showed to be the 4:7 salt. Fusion with sodium hydroxide also yielded a mass which after extraction with water deposited the 4:7 salt.

3.

The best method by which the 4:7 salt can be prepared is by the addition of acetic acid to a solution of sodium metavanadate, the solution being concentrated to crystallisation by evaporation in vacuo over sulphuric acid at room temperature. By this method large well-formed crystals can be obtained, washed free from mother-liquid and dried in a current of air. The amount of acetic acid may vary from one mol to three mols of acid per mol of sodium vanadate, but, although the same polyvanadate is formed in each case, two mols of acid give the best-formed crystals.

4.

This polyvanadate has also been formed by the treatment of 1 mol. of sodium orthovanadate in solution with 2.5 mols of perchloric acid, crystallisation being effected by evaporation in vacuo.

– 394 –
5.

Prepared by any of these methods the salt can be recrystallised from aqueous solution.

6.

Addition of alcohol to any of these solutions precipitates a vivid yellow, apparently amorphous powder which changes over a period of days to small orange-red crystals. Analysis of the yellow powder showed that it has the same composition as the red crystals and the colour difference must, therefore, be brought about by particle size. This alcohol precipitation helps to free the salt from traces of adhering solution of sodium acetate or perchlorate.

The best preparation is secured by adding two mols of acetic acid to one of sodium metavanadate, throwing down the polyvanadate by addition of alcohol and then recrystallizing from water by evaporation over sulphuric acid in vacuo.

Analysis of Polyvanadate.

Twenty-four analyses of this polyvanadate have been made. The percentages of Na2O and V2O2 so found we do not regard as significant by themselves, because it was always difficult to determine the point at which air drying ceased to remove adhering moisture and began to cause efflorescence. The significance of the analyses can be better appreciated if they are expressed as molar ratios of Na2O: V2O5. The following table summarizes the analyses in this form:—

Type of preparation. No. of analyses. Na2O : V2O5
Boiling with Carbonate 3 1 : 1.767
NaVO3 + HAc 2 1 : 1.735
Na3VO4 + HClO4 3 1 : 1.749
Alcohol precipitation 4 1 : 1.754
Recrystallisation 12 1 : 1.757

The last two methods of preparation give the most reliable analyses, and it is evident that the simplest compound with this analysis would be 4Na2O,7V2O5. Taking into consideration the appearance of the crystals before analysis, i.e., the appearance of moisture or efflorescence, we believe that the most reliable formula is 4Na2O,7V2O5,33H2O although our most reliable analyses would not be markedly inconsistent with the formulation 4Na2O,7V2O5,34H2O.

– 395 –

An analysis of this salt by the method of Kiehl and Manfredo corresponded to 4Na2O,6.89V2O5,34H2O but we do not consider this method of analysis so reliable.

Crystallography of Polyvanadate.

We are greatly indebted to Dr. F. J. Turner for an examination of crystals of this polyvanadate. His report is as follows:—

Habit variable as a result of a tendency for crystals to be flattened parallel to any one of the three forms (l, g and h) of the principal zone. Two other zones (containing l x and y, or l m and n respectively) may be developed, but usually either m and n or x and y are omitted. The following angles, measured from ten different crystals, are probably correct to ±5′.

  • lg = 42° 30′

  • gh = 49° 5′

  • hl′ = 88° 25

  • lm′ = 56° 52′

  • mn = 59° 17′

  • ln = 63° 51′

  • xg = 46° 51′

  • m′g = 48° 36′

  • xl = 56° 52′

  • xy = 61° 25′

– 396 –

Symmetry appears to be triclinic, closely approaching monoclinic (the axis of the principal zone is almost an axis of binary symmetry). Microscopically examined, the crystals are biaxial, negative, and distinctly pleochroic (α < δ).

Preparation of a Polyvanadate unstable at 25°.

Occasionally in the course of the above preparations the salt formed could be seen to be heterogeneous and a second polyvanadate could be separated by hand from the mass of crystals. The formation of these brownish-orange lath-like crystals was favoured by low temperature, e.g., if the evaporation in vacuo were conducted in the ice chest. Otherwise their formation seemed to be fortuitous and not controllable, but as they could not be recrystallized from water without decomposition into pentoxide and the 4:7 salt, and no sign could be found in the subsequent phase rule investigation of their stable existence at 25°, this polyvanadate does not concern the 25° isotherm. The mean of five analyses gave to this salt the formula Na2O, 1.99V2O5,10H2O. The crystallographic features, measured by Dr. F. J. Turner, are as follows:—

Habit lathy, flattened parallel to the optic axial plane. Extinction angle(δ to direction of elongation) = 23°.Distinct pleochroism (δ = orange, α = lemon-yellow, δ>α). Good cleavage parallel to elongation, crossed at 85° by a less perfect transverse cleavage (δ lies in the acute angle of intersection of the cleavages).

The 3:5 Polyvanadate.

We obtained a number of analyses corresponding approximately to the salt 3Na2O,5V2O5,22H2O but these were always obtained from solutions with a higher ratio of Na2O:V2O5 under experimental conditions which excluded washing the crystals free from mother liquid. A crystallographic examination by Dr. Turner showed that they were identical with authentic crystals of the 4:7 salts and we concluded that sufficient mother liquid had been left entangled with the crystals to give a misleading analysis. We do not, therefore, claim the existence of this salt.

Equilibria with the coloured Polyvanadate.

By using different mixtures of sodium metavanadate, the 4:7 and 1:2 salts and the solution obtained by saturating sodium carbonate solution with vanadium pentoxide, it was possible to follow the equilibria between solid and saturated solutions of composition between the metavanadate and what was practically an aqueous solution of vanadium pentoxide. The last three lines of Table I refer to solutions prepared from the 4:7 salt with sodium metavanadate as solid phase. The remainder of the analyses are given in Table II.

– 397 –

[The section below cannot be correctly rendered as it contains complex formatting. See the image of the page for a more accurate rendering.]

Table II.
The System Na2O–V2O5–H2O At 25°—(Continued).
Liquid phase. Solid phase. Solid.
%Na2O %V2O5 %Na2O %V2O5
3.89 14.38
3.75 13.78 12.42 61.95
3.49 14.28 10.30 51.12
3.04 14.89 10.30 56.74
3.09 15.83 11.13 56.16
3.21 15.76
3.03 16.04 9.37 51.88
3.23 16.20 4Na2O,7V2O5,33H2O
3.24 17.13 9.68 55.59
3.39 17.82 11.56 59.51
3.79 21.11 10.83 52.89
4.98 28.17 10.24 55.74
5.04 29.34 11.14 57.25
5.20 30.35 11.25 56.55
5.24 31.02 10.90 58.99
4.64 28.70 7.44 46.44
3.42 24.03 4.30 37.11
3.48 22.38 3.68 48.16
2.76 18.64 10.18 51.97
2.30 16.47 9.68 50.41 “V2O5
2.11 15.25
2.16 13.93
1.29 9.07 5.90 32.88
0.73 4.43

A triangular diagram is not satisfactory for illustrating the equilibria in this region; tie-lines drawn on a large scale on such a diagram show that the first set of lines in the above table converge on a point but the angle subtended by the liquidus is too small to enable the composition of the solid phase to be determined with certainty. We relied therefore on the appearance of the solid phase and the analyses of the purified polyvanadate to characterise it as the 4:7 salt. A graph in which mols of Na2O per 100 gram of solution are plotted against mols V2O5 per 100 grams of solution (Fig. II) shows the equilibria very clearly, giving two loops characteristic of solutions in equilibrium with the metavanadate and the polyvanadate and a third region which we have denoted “V2O5.” On a triangular diagram the tie-lines in this region do not converge on a point, although some of them pass close to the point for the 4:7 salt, yet their non-crystalline appearance showed that they represent a different equilibrium. We conclude that those solutions are in equilibrium with vanadium pentoxide containing loosely combined adsorbed alkali.

– 398 –

Summary.

The system Na2O–V2O5–H2O can be in equilibrium at 25° with eight solid phases, viz. NaOH,H2O; Na3VO4,2½H2O; Na3VO4,7H2O; Na3VO4,12H2O; Na4V2O7,18H2O; NaVO3,2H2O; 4 Na2O,7V2O5,33 (or 34) H2O; and vanadium pentoxide containing adsorbed alkali.

Only one polyvanadate is stable at 25° and optimum conditions for its preparation are described. A second polyvanadate has been isolated and appears to be more stable at lower temperatures.

References.

Baker, H.—J. Chem. Soc., 47, 357 (1885).

Britton, H. T. S., and Robinson, R. A.—J. Chem. Soc., 2328 (1930).

Ditte, A.—Compt. rend., 104, 902, 1061 (1887).

Hall, J. A.—J. Chem. Soc., 51, 94 (1887).

Kiehl, S. J., and Manfredo, E. J.—J. Amer. Chem. Soc., 59, 2118 (1937).

McAdam, D. J., and Pierle, C. A.—J. Amer. Chem. Soc., 34, 604 (1912).

Roscoe, H. E.—J. Chem. Soc., 24, 23 (1871).